advertisement

Arkush: There's no doubt Smith can play, but is he a fit for the Bears?

Could anything have been more appropriate Thursday night in the first round of the 2018 NFL draft than the Bears at No. 8 selecting Roquan Smith - the first Butkus Award winner to ever play for the Bears - in the same year Brian Urlacher will join Butkus, Bill George and Mike Singletary in the Hall of Fame?

There can be no doubt that Smith was high on the list of eight players general manager Ryan Pace said the Bears would have been happy to have at No. 8.

Three quarterbacks - Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold and Josh Allen - were among the first seven taken with the Bills trading directly in front of the Bears to select Allen with Tampa Bay's choice, so we know at least four of Pace's favorites were there if not more.

Also available and likely to have been on the Bears' list were safeties Minkah Fitzpatrick and Derwin James, and edge rushers Marcus Davenport and Tremaine Edmunds - two positions of greater need than the inside linebacker spot Smith will man, so there is little doubt Pace believes he got the best football player.

It is also worth noting the Raiders traded their No. 10 pick down to 15 with Arizona, the Packers traded out of the 14th spot, and the Ravens traded out of the 16th spot, so it is quite likely there was a deal to be made had Pace preferred to trade down to acquire more picks.

Clearly, Pace and the Bears got their guy.

Now we are left to wonder whether they got the right guy and what they will do to address remaining significant needs with their second-round pick on Day 2 and five remaining picks on Day 3.

The pick was wildly popular with a huge crowd of Bears fans that gathered at Soldier Field for the team's draft party, and it also has been extremely well-received by the local media, with almost half of those gathered at Halas Hall predicting Smith was the Bears' guy.

I have nothing negative to say about the choice. There is little doubt in my mind Smith is one of the three or four best defensive prospects in this draft, and the Bears got much better value with Smith at 8 than the Browns did reaching for cornerback Denzel Ward at 4, or the three clubs taking quarterbacks got.

My only nagging doubt about the pick is whether Smith - who I think ideally should be a weakside inside linebacker in a 4-3 defense, quite possibly the next Derek Brooks or a much faster Lance Briggs - is a good fit for the Bears and Vic Fangio's 3-4 base package.

Smith is undersized to play inside in the NFL, but not that much smaller than Navarro Bowman who, along with Patrick Willis, played inside linebacker when Fangio was running the 49ers' Super Bowl and NFC title game defenses, of which Bowman and Willis were the heart and soul.

In Smith and Danny Trevathan, the Bears are likely to have two guys who never come off the field and should be able to cover receivers as well as any linebackers in the league.

But the Bears had a top-10 defense last year with Trevathan, Christian Jones and Nick Kwiatkoski inside, and what they need desperately to improve upon that group is pass rush and another playmaker at safety, neither of which are improved by Smith's presence.

Akiem Hicks plays the game quite reminiscent of the way all-pro Justin Smith did for Fangio in San Francisco, and with Smith and Trevathan here apparently to clone Willis and Bowman (not quite as big but quicker and more athletic), what is still missing is a version of Aldon Smith to pair with Leonard Floyd and an upgrade for Adrian Amos.

Assuming the Bears stand pat at 39 in the second round, if any of Harold Landry, Arden Key, Lorenzo Carter or Duke Ejiofor are still available, one of them could be the pick that makes Smith that much more special.

• Hub Arkush, the executive editor of Pro Football Weekly, can be reached at harkush@profootballweekly.com or on Twitter @Hub_Arkush.

Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the "flag" link in the lower-right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.