An early holiday treat: Drury Lane’s warm-hearted ‘Annie’ will make audiences smile
“Annie” ― 3.5 stars
Less than three weeks before the opening of Drury Lane Theatre’s “Annie” revival, Emerson Mae Chan learned that she would be taking over the titular role.
You’d never guess it from the performance the pint-size pro delivered on opening night.
Free of the contrived precociousness some child actors affect, Chan was spirited and confident.
Originally cast as the alternate Annie, Chan was to substitute for principal Catharina Araujo for some performances. But Araujo experienced vocal strain during rehearsals, which prompted the two 11-year-old actors to switch duties. Araujo now plays the orphan Kate, substituting for Chan at select performances.
Sporting an impish grin and possessed of an outsize voice, Chan endeared herself to theatergoers from the first notes of “Maybe,” the plaintive ode to Annie’s absent parents that opens the show.
She had them eating out of her hand not long after, belting out the show’s signature “Tomorrow” while sitting beside canine co-star Georgie, who plays Sandy.
Inspired by Harold Gray’s “Little Orphan Annie” comic strip, which ran from 1924 until the cartoonist’s death in 1968, “Annie” is a tuner in the classic Broadway tradition. Sentimental and uncomplicated, with cartoon villains and a happy ending, “Annie” boasts a bouncy score by Charles Strouse, clever lyrics by Martin Charnin and a wry, funny book by Thomas Meehan.
Director Scott Weinstein embraces the old-school style. Warm-hearted and sweet without being sappy, Weinstein’s production is propelled by honest, enthusiastic performances from the actors. The cast is accompanied by conductor/keyboardist Christopher Sargent’s sextet, which sounds larger than it is.
The time is 1933, a few weeks before Christmas. The place is New York City, ever-present thanks to Jose Santiago’s illuminated skyline.
Annie and her fellow foundlings (Ava Rose Doty, Elin Joy Seiler, Avelyn Lena Choi, Emma Catherine Ritter, Mae Rose O’Connell and Araujo as Kate) live in New York in a wretched orphanage. It is overseen by the boozy, embittered Miss Hannigan, played by Kelly Felthous, whose performance is the latest in a series of deliciously comedic turns by the actress.
Grace Farrell (Allison Sill), secretary to Oliver Warbucks (Anand Nagraj), the only billionaire to survive the Great Depression, shows up to invite one of the orphans to spend the holiday at Warbucks’ mansion. Money inspires designer Tijana Bjelajac’s plush, green and gold set, which contrasts sharply with the dingy gray of the orphanage.
Enamored of the plucky orphan, Nagraj’s Warbucks offers $50,000 to Annie’s parents if they come forward to claim her. Upon learning of the reward, ex-con Rooster Hannigan (the terrific Jackson Evans) and his gold-digger girlfriend Lily St. Regis (Amanda Walker, also terrific) concoct a scheme with his sister Miss Hannigan to get the reward by pretending to be her folks.
The Felthous-Evans-Walker trio nearly stopped the show with the vaudeville-inspired “Easy Street,” in which Miss Hannigan, Rooster and Lily imagine the life Warbucks’ money will provide. Other highlights include the frenetic “I Think I’m Gonna Like It Here” and the charming “You’re Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile.”
Chan and Nagraj make an endearing pair as evidenced by their performance of “I Don’t Need Anything But You.” Also deserving mention are Ron E. Rains as FDR and Ed Kross as Warbucks’ butler Drake, whose supporting performances earn laughs without stealing focus.
• • •
Location: Drury Lane Theatre, 100 Drury Lane, Oakbrook Terrace, 630-530-0111, drurylanetheatre.com
Showtimes: 1:30 p.m. Wednesday; 1:30 and 7 p.m. Thursday; 7 p.m. Friday; 3 and 8 p.m. Saturday; and 2 and 6 p.m. Sunday, through Jan. 10, 2027
Tickets: $85-$160; dinner theater packages available
Running time: About 2 hours, 20 minutes with intermission
Parking: Free in the adjacent lot
Rating: For all audiences