Hub Arkush: Bears get a 'W' but it's winning ugly again
Picking the Bears over the New York Giants Sunday was easy, but not quite as easy as it was to predict they'd struggle to get it done.
But before we get back to trying to figure out just how far south this season that started with such promise for the Bears has gone, let's give a little credit where it is due.
Yes, the Giants are a bad football team and the New York offense has struggled for a good part of the year. But they do have some weapons - including one of the game's best young running backs - and for a good part of the day Sunday the Bears defense did a few things that felt a lot like 2018.
A couple of mental errors from Eddie Jackson made this one close, but Khalil Mack spent most of the second half imposing his will on the Giants. Leonard Floyd got angry, Ha Ha Clinton Dix has been playing really good football for a few weeks, and even though he may not get to go because of his club's poor play, Kyle Fuller should be planning for his second straight Pro Bowl trip. And the defensive front spent the day telling rookie Daniel Jones you better beat us through the air because we're not going to let Saquon Barkley do it on the ground.
All that said, overall, ugly was once again the color of the day.
To be fair, this one probably isn't close if Mitch Trubisky doesn't throw a pick in the end zone late in the 1st quarter on the Bears second possession after driving 77 yards on 12 plays, they don't get a hands-to-the-face penalty on Cody Whitehair wiping out a 60-yard Trubisky to Allen Robinson connection on their third possession and Ben Braunecker doesn't drop an easy touchdown catch late in the 2nd quarter forcing them to punt.
But in many respects the fact that all of those things consistently keep happening is exactly the problem with where this team is at right now.
This 19-14 Bears win is one you can go back and watch and find mistakes by almost everyone on offense and a handful of players on defense, but fixing the problems just isn't as simple as those players not making the same mistakes again.
Asked after the game how he balances the continued breakdowns of his offense versus the importance of getting another game in the win column Matt Nagy said, "Yeah, well, number one, we don't accept it, so that's the first part is making sure, okay, how can we be better in that area.
"But I think it's both sides, and you don't want - coming out with the win, you're proud of that, but we want to make sure that - I think we all pride ourselves, I know I do, on making sure that stuff doesn't happen."
Clearly communication is a problem for these Bears right now, but not the whole problem.
The Bears running game is nonexistent and it's not for lack of effort.
Against the Giants Nagy called 25 passes and 26 runs, the kind of balance always aspired to but rarely achieved.
But the Bears managed just 65 yards on those 26 runs and far more damning, if you strip out longs of 13 yards for Tarik Cohen and David Montgomery and a 12 yard scramble from Trubisky, the Bears managed only 27 yards on the other 23 attempts, a 1.2 average.
It is practically impossible to establish an offense with that kind of ground game and equally difficult to stack first downs and give your defense a blow or run a 4:00 offense in the fourth quarter which is why no matter who the Bears play they're always hanging around late.
It was great to see the Bears climb back to within a game of .500, but nothing got fixed or really even improved Sunday vs. the Giants, and we've been talking about failings in the ground game since Nagy arrived.
It's hard to say whether it's scheme, play-calling, coaching, talent or more the O-line's fault than the backs or both, but it' easy to see nothing is likely to get better for this offense until they figure that out, and wins could be scarce the rest of this season.
• Hub Arkush, the executive editor of Pro Football Weekly, can be reached at harkush@profootballweekly.com or on Twitter @Hub_Arkush.