advertisement

Mount Prospect man goes undercover for government

A Mount Prospect man who went undercover for the FBI to help expose fraud by the Skokie defense contractor he worked for will collect millions as a whistle-blower.

Joe Caputo, a longtime pricing analyst for MPC Products Corp. in Skokie, stands to collect 15 percent to 25 percent of a $22.5 million civil settlement between the company and the government, according to his attorneys. He was represented in the case by Palatine employment lawyer Dennis Favaro, who worked with a California attorney specializing in whistle-blower cases.

The settlement resolves procurement fraud allegations that the Department of Defense was falsely billed over seven years.

"I'm proud to have been able to help taxpayers recover dollars that were being wasted" Caputo said in a news release. "The agents were great to work with. And now that it's over, I've got my life back."

Skokie-based MPC, acquired in October 2008 by Woodward Governor Co. and renamed Woodward MPC Inc., also will pay $2.5 million in fines in a related criminal prosecution, the U.S. Department of Justice said.

In the settlement, MPC denied liability, wrongdoing or improper conduct.

Woodward MPC had been debarred by the Pentagon from government contracts for about a year until it recently reached a three-year agreement with the government which includes enhanced ethics implementation.

Favaro declined to comment on the case, beyond what was in a news release and court documents. Caputo couldn't be reached for comment Friday.

Caputo had been fired on a pretext in fall 2000 after refusing his employer's instructions to continue falsifying documents which were being provided to the government, his attorneys said in a news release. He was rehired approximately a year later, resuming his duties but secretly cooperating undercover with federal authorities, gathering information that led to the settlement.

Caputo took personal risks to secretly record workplace conversations for the authorities and then, with attorneys Mark Allen Kleiman of Venice, Calif., and Favaro, spent more than 1,000 hours helping government investigators analyze company accounting documents.

"Joe was a real hero in this case. He took great risks over the years. He and his family put up with tremendous hardships to make this investigation work," Kleiman said in a news release.

"As our fraud investigation unfolded, we saw its extent and went straight to the government. It was Joe's knowledge and persistence in teaming up with government investigators which made this case work," Favaro said in a release.

The defense fraud schemes employed by MPC were designed to maintain high profit margins and help win private industry contracts by creating false pricing data. The government paid high prices for MPC parts. This same payment record allowed MPC to discount their rates to private industry in which it sought to gain a greater foothold, according to court documents.

According to the complaint, a few of the interlocking schemes used by MPC to conduct the defense contracting fraud included:

• Inflating material costs by overwriting actual costs in a computer record, printing out the false documentation and then "reverting" the internal data back to the correct costs;

• Inflating labor required by deciding first how many hours MPC needed to show for a project then transferring hours from other projects to the one to be inflated; and

• Using lower grade parts than those specified.

In one example of overpricing cited in court documents, the government paid $176,000 for a F/A 18 Throttle Quadrant Assembly taken from an already inventoried production run of 60 assemblies, each of which cost about $60,000.

The federal False Claims Act allows private citizens with knowledge of fraud to help the government recover ill-gotten gains and additional civil penalties. The FCA allows the government to collect up to three times the amount it was defrauded, in addition to civil penalties of $5,500 to $11,000 per false claim.