Great Lakes water temperatures blowing away records
You don't expect to see 75 or even 80-degree water in the Great Lakes in early July or, in most years, anytime. But an exceptionally hot weather pattern has pushed water temperatures in most of the lakes to the highest levels on record so early in the summer. Over lakes Erie and Ontario, the water is the warmest it has been since the records began, and could warm more in the coming weeks.
The abnormally warm waters, consistent with climate change trends in recent decades, could compromise water quality and harm marine life in some areas.
Surface water temperatures averaged over all of the Great Lakes, except the deep and choppy Lake Superior, have risen well into the 70s while Lake Erie has flirted with 80 degrees. That's about the same water temperature as the surf off Virginia Beach, Va.
These water temperatures over the lakes are some 6 to 11 degrees warmer than normal.
Here is how warm each of the lakes has become over the past week:
Lake Michigan's average water temperature reached 75.1 degrees on July 8, nearly 11 degrees above normal, and the warmest mark on record so early in the year. The water temperature in July has only been this warm one other time, at the end of the month in 1999.
Lake Huron's average water temperature reached 72.2 degrees on July 9, nearly 11 degrees above normal, and the warmest mark on record so early in the year.
Lake Ontario's average water temperature reached 77.1 degrees on July 10, over 10 degrees above normal, and the warmest mark on record for any month, although it was similarly warm in mid-August 1995.
Lake Erie's average water temperature reached 79.6 degrees on July 10, over 8 degrees above normal, and the warmest mark on record for any month, also similarly warm in mid-August 1995.
Lake Superior average water temperature reached 55.8 degrees on July 8, over 6 degrees above normal.
The unusually warm water is a reflection of blistering heat over the Great Lakes region in recent weeks set up by a persistent ridge of high pressure.
Air temperatures in early July, especially in the eastern Great Lakes, were among the warmest on record.
Buffalo hit at least 90 degrees on eight straight days ending Friday, its longest streak ever observed. Muskegon, Mich., on the shores of Lake Michigan, also notched its longest 90-degree streak, tallying nine straight ending July 7.
Massena, N.Y., about 90 miles north of Lake Ontario in upstate New York, hit 99 degrees Friday, its second highest temperature ever recorded.
The heat has meant water temperatures are "abnormally high compared to the most recent years," said Andrea VanderWoude, manager of the Great Lakes CoastWatch program at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. "Last year was really cold and there was a lot of rain. This year there hasn't been as much rain and it's been persistently hot."
The water temperatures spiked late last week before a weekend cold front unleashed windy, stormy weather which helped draw deep, cold water back toward the surface of the lake, in a process known as upwelling. This has caused water temperatures to drop slightly.
But VanderWoude expects they will rise again. Historically, water temperatures in Great Lakes reach their maximum in August
"We haven't even reached the tip of that curve that usually occurs later [in the summer]," she said.
The National Weather Service's Climate Prediction Center favors above normal temperatures over the Great Lakes in its 6 to 10- and 8 to 14-day outlooks and a slight risk for "excessive heat." Computer models forecast a high pressure ridge or "heat dome" to sprawl over the eastern half of the Lower 48 for much of this period.
This heat could push water temperatures to historic levels across all of the lakes with the likely exception of Superior.
Some residents are rejoicing in the unusually warm waters.
"I'm loving this," Whitney Miller, a Traverse City, Mich.-based swim instructor, told the Record-Eagle, a newspaper serving the region. "Last year I was in a wetsuit up through the 15th of July ... I was a popsicle."
But the warm water could have detrimental effects on water quality and some aquatic species.
VanderWoude says NOAA aircraft have already photographed blue-green algae or cyanbacteria over western waters of Lake Erie in recent days. The foul-smelling algal blooms can harm fish and make people who are exposed to the water sick. In 2014, cyanbacteria from Lake Erie entered the water supply in Toledo, Ohio, and residents were ordered not to drink or touch the water.
The jump start to the algal bloom due to the warm water temperatures means it will be around for several weeks longer than normal.
"This is the second earliest we've seen [the algae] in our data since 2002," wrote Richad Stumpf, an oceanographer with NOAA, in an email. "The earliest was in late June in 2018."
Because phosphorous levels, which make algal blooms worse, aren't particularly high due to less rain than some years, Stumpf doesn't anticipate this year's bloom to be among the biggest. But "it will still be quite visible and is a risk that people need to avoid," he said.
NOAA publishes regular algal bloom forecasts and updates on its website.
In addition to the effects from algal blooms, Stumpf said the warm water can have other detrimental effects for fish. "Many fish do not do well in water that is too warm, so they get 'squeezed' into a smaller and smaller area between surface water that is too warm, and bottom water that doesn't have enough oxygen," he wrote.
The record-setting waters this July fit into the recent warming trend observed over the Great Lakes tied to climate change. "[E]very Great Lake has warmed at least 1.5 F since 1995 (when data became available for all lakes), led by Lake Ontario at 2.2 F," wrote Climate Central, the science communications non-profit, in 2019.