Happy owners don't write about timeshares

Q. It seems like all I read about timeshares is how awful they are to get rid of, and how people are unhappy with them. Are there folks who like their timeshare? Is it a case of you only hearing about the problems, not the successes? If I were interested in one, what would your advice be?

A. I'm sure there are lots of people who enjoy owning timeshares, and I'm sure you're right that they're not the ones who write to me.

My advice would be: Don't regard a timeshare as an investment. It's not a parcel of real estate that can be expected to increase in value. Most timeshares are eventually resold at an average of less than 10 percent of the original cost.

Timeshare ownership can be a convenient, inexpensive way to vacation in the same place every year. Sometimes there's a way to exchange timeshares with other owners for variety, but don't count on that. And years from now, when your family's needs have changed, understand that it may cost something to get free of it.

Owning a timeshare can be a money-saving, trouble-free convenience, but it shouldn't be considered an investment.

Q. You recently suggested approaching lenders for financial analysis. I agree lenders/bankers do provide information. However, I would enter a caveat there.

They are in the business of making loans and are going to tell you the maximum you could possibly borrow/spend. That's not necessarily what you really can afford or need to spend.

You need to ask yourself whether you want to have extra cash at the end of the month to maybe plant some trees, paint a room, visit a restaurant or go on vacation. Having purchased homes in Texas, Pennsylvania and New York, I can say that once the bankers see you can afford a certain amount, the Realtors and bankers push you to spend that much.

But if you want to be financially sound, spend less than you can afford. I have found it to be a very good lesson learned.

A. I agree with your advice to spend less than the maximum you may be offered. There's nothing wrong, though, with finding out how much you could qualify to borrow. That's what bankers will tell you, and they should.

The real estate brokers I know are much more interested in putting together a trouble-free deal than in squeezing people for their last dime. Years ago, when I had a real estate license, I was delighted with people who didn't want to spend more just because they could. Knowing they would easily qualify for a loan made house hunting a particularly pleasant experience.

My guess is that most agents would say the same thing. And I suspect lenders also find it relaxing to deal with well-qualified - overqualified - buyers.

There's nothing wrong, though, with finding out how much you could borrow if you want to.

Q. This is not a question but a complaint.

We are nearing retirement age and ready to downsize, but the only smaller houses are in senior communities. We want new construction in a multigenerational neighborhood, but builders keep building larger houses, many with a lot of wasted footage, which makes the houses unaffordable. Retirees, couples with no children, frequent travelers and even busy young professionals who don't want the headache of maintaining a large home are left with no choice.

Thus, we will stay in our present home. I am guessing there are many more in our situation. I look forward to your next column.

A. I suppose what you're looking for might be found in an older neighborhood, which is more likely to hold a variety of homes. Newer developments may have building code restrictions on the theory that maximum value is reached when everything in a neighborhood is more or less the same size and costs about the same.

Keep looking. Your new retirement home is out there somewhere - in a mixed neighborhood - just waiting for you.

Q. I am attending my senior year in high school, and we have a term paper that has to be 50 to 100 pages typed. I need information, and I am doing it on the housing industry and real estate. Please send me all information you have, 50 to 100 pages typed.

A. Sorry, but I don't feel like writing your term paper for you.

• Contact Edith Lank on, or 240 Hemingway Drive, Rochester NY 14620.

© 2018, Creators Syndicate

Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the "flag" link in the lower-right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.