Breaking News Bar
updated: 12/7/2017 12:56 PM

DA issues criticism of judge in Penn State frat death case

hello
Success - Article sent! close
  • FILE- In this Aug. 31, 2017, file photo, District Judge Allen Sinclair arrives for the seventh day of preliminary hearings at the Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. Sinclair threw out involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault charges against eight defendants in death of Tim Piazza in September. A hearing on Thursday, Dec. 7, will determine whether a new district judge will preside over what will be a second preliminary hearing, as prosecutors pursue reinstated criminal charges in the death of Piazza. (Phoebe Sheehan/Centre Daily Times via AP, File)

    FILE- In this Aug. 31, 2017, file photo, District Judge Allen Sinclair arrives for the seventh day of preliminary hearings at the Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. Sinclair threw out involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault charges against eight defendants in death of Tim Piazza in September. A hearing on Thursday, Dec. 7, will determine whether a new district judge will preside over what will be a second preliminary hearing, as prosecutors pursue reinstated criminal charges in the death of Piazza. (Phoebe Sheehan/Centre Daily Times via AP, File)
    Associated Press

  • FILE- In this Sept. 1, 2017, file photo, Magisterial District Judge Allen Sinclair, left, leaves the Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. Sinclair threw out involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault charges against eight defendants in death of Tim Piazza. A hearing on Thursday, Dec. 7, will determine whether a new district judge will preside over what will be a second preliminary hearing, as prosecutors pursue reinstated criminal charges in the death of Piazza. (John Boogert/Centre Daily Times via AP, File)

    FILE- In this Sept. 1, 2017, file photo, Magisterial District Judge Allen Sinclair, left, leaves the Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. Sinclair threw out involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault charges against eight defendants in death of Tim Piazza. A hearing on Thursday, Dec. 7, will determine whether a new district judge will preside over what will be a second preliminary hearing, as prosecutors pursue reinstated criminal charges in the death of Piazza. (John Boogert/Centre Daily Times via AP, File)
    Associated Press

 
 

BELLEFONTE, Pa. -- A prosecutor on Thursday sharply criticized a judge over her handling of the case against former Penn State fraternity members charged in a pledge's drinking death.

"While this case may be unusual and novel in complexity and number of defendants, the court has an obligation to handle it properly and be fair to both sides," Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller wrote in a statement. "To date, it has failed miserably."

Parks Miller was not in the courtroom as her seven-page news release was issued at the same time that Common Pleas Court Judge Pamela Ruest presided over a hearing on the fate of dismissed charges.

Parks Miller said Ruest would not let her participate by phone from out of town.

After a brief court recess, Ruest gave lawyers copies of the release and said she would address it later in the hearing.

Ruest has to decide whether to appoint a new magisterial district judge to handle re-filed charges in the Feb. 4 death of 19-year-old Tim Piazza of Lebanon, New Jersey.

Twenty-six people currently face criminal charges related to Piazza's death, which occurred two days after he suffered a series of falls and consumed a dangerous amount of alcohol during a pledge bid night at the Penn State chapter of Beta Theta Pi. Some fraternity members face charges that could result in prison terms, while others are accused of hazing and alcohol violations.

After an unusually hard-fought preliminary hearing, which lasted seven days over three months, District Judge Allen Sinclair on Sept. 1 threw out many of the charges, including the most serious allegations of involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault. The district attorney subsequently refiled many of those counts and sought a new judge.

Sinclair "simply did not understand the theory and made many incongruous rulings by binding over some charges and dismissing others," prosecutor Michael Osterberg argued.

Defense attorneys told Ruest that Sinclair's decision did not amount to legal error, so the dismissed charges should not be revived.

"Just because you disagree with the judge's ruling doesn't give you a second bite," argued defense attorney Ted Simon.

Sinclair also ruled there was evidence to send other charges to for trial, and they are currently pending in county court.

On Nov. 13, Parks Miller announced the FBI had helped recover erased security camera footage from the fraternity basement, providing evidence that Piazza had been given at least 18 drinks over less than 90 minutes.

That led her to file entirely new charges. A preliminary hearing for those "basement tapes" charges, which had been scheduled for next week in Bellefonte, has been postponed.

Security camera footage documented how Piazza became visibly inebriated early in the evening, after which fraternity members made ineffective and even counterproductive efforts to help him. He had suffered a fractured skull, shattered spleen and other injuries.

Fraternity members found his unconscious body in the basement the next morning, but waited about 40 minutes before summoning help.

Parks Miller, defeated in the spring Democratic primary, leaves office at the end of this month. Her successor, Democrat Bernie Cantorna, has indicated he will ask the state attorney general's office to take over the prosecution.

Article Comments ()
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.