Prosecutors oppose Calusinski's new trial request

  • Melissa Calusinski

    Melissa Calusinski

Updated 1/4/2016 4:42 PM

Lake County prosecutors have filed a motion to dismiss a new trial request for a Carpentersville woman who claims she is wrongfully incarcerated for a toddler's 2009 death at a Lincolnshire day care center.

In the 37-page court document filed Dec. 31, prosecutors said the alleged "new" X-ray evidence introduced in a post-conviction petition by defense attorneys for Melissa Calusinski, 28, was actually old evidence her attorneys had in their possession but never electronically enhanced.


In addition, prosecutors said the post-trial petition filed in June by defense attorney Kathleen Zellner reintroduces old arguments that were already discounted at Calusinski's 2011 trial.

"This was a complex trial involving many experts and witnesses, and not something that can be summarized in a sound bite," Lake County State's Attorney Michael Nerheim said Monday. "We filed our petition and will discuss our argument in a court of law where it belongs."

The prosecution document, which the Daily Herald obtained Monday, is under review by Lake County Judge Daniel Shanes. It will be discussed at a hearing Jan. 8.

Calusinski was sentenced to 31 years in prison after a jury convicted her of first-degree murder in the death of 16-month-old Benjamin Kingan. Calusinski was found guilty of throwing the Deerfield boy to the floor at the now-closed Minee Subee in the Park day care in Lincolnshire, causing a fatal head injury.

by signing up you agree to our terms of service

After an appeal was denied by the state appellate court in February 2014, Zellner claimed in a post-trial petition that a second set of legible autopsy X-rays taken of the toddler's skull clearly showed the child suffered from a pre-existing injury when he died.

That petition also states an anonymous caller told Calusinski's father, Paul Calusinski, to find an enhanced set of X-rays at the Lake County coroner's office. Paul Calusinski contacted Coroner Thomas Rudd, who found the X-rays, the document states.

However, prosecutors said in their latest filing that defense attorneys were in possession of the X-rays two months before Calusinski's previous trial but never enhanced them using a computer program that could make them more legible.

Prosecutors also claim in the court document the X-rays do not negate the fact Calusinski was found guilty of throwing Benjamin to the floor. Whether Benjamin had a previous head injury or not is irrelevant because a jury found Calusinski's actions were a contributing factor in the death, prosecutors said.

If a new trial is granted, it would take place later this year, officials said.

Zellner said in a previous interview she is "confident" the court will award Calusinski a new trial.

Article Comments
Attention: We are experiencing technical difficulties with our Facebook Comments module at this time. Comments will remain disabled until we are able to resolve the problem. We apologize for the interruption. We invite you to engage with our content and talk with other commenters on our Daily Herald Facebook page at Thank you.