advertisement

Illinois consumers see higher prices and fewer choices for Obamacare health insurance

If anyone knows the importance of having good health insurance, it’s Dafna Fink, but the cost of her Affordable Care Act exchange plan has become increasingly difficult to bear.

Just a couple of years ago, Fink and her husband Shaanan Fink were paying less than $200 a month for their exchange plan, she said. That cost has skyrocketed to about $750 a month for next year.

The Skokie couple buy health insurance through Illinois’ exchange at GetCovered.Illinois.gov because neither of them are eligible for coverage through employers. Dafna Fink has a number of health issues, including seizures and autoimmune conditions that have left her unable to work, and her husband is a self-employed contractor who relies on his flexible schedule to help care for her and their children.

“This is the No. 1 most important thing in our life, is the plan, and it’s a fight every year and every year it goes up in cost,” said Dafna Fink, 46. “And we don’t make any more money. If anything, we make less, and all the costs in life are going up. How does anybody afford this?”

The Finks are among many Illinois residents facing higher prices, and, in some cases, fewer choices as they shop for health insurance on the state’s Affordable Care Act exchange, or Obamacare exchange, this open enrollment season. Open enrollment for exchange plans in Illinois started Nov. 1, and goes through Dec. 15 for those who want coverage starting Jan. 1. For coverage starting Feb. 1, people have until Jan. 15 to select plans.

Some experts are hopeful that the recent election of Democratic majorities in Congress will lead to more affordable exchange plans. But any changes wouldn’t likely come in time for consumers now sifting through their options.

Across Illinois, monthly premiums for the lowest cost bronze, silver and gold plans are between 10% and 14% higher, on average, for next year compared with this year, according to an analysis by the Illinois Department of Insurance.

Also, though Cook County residents will have several more plans to choose from this year, consumers in Lake, McHenry, Kane, DuPage, Will and Kankakee counties, among others, will have fewer choices.

“It’s a really hard time,” said Kathy Waligora, deputy director of external affairs for EverThrive Illinois, an organization focused on reproductive justice, of this year’s open enrollment season. “Most people on the exchange are still going to find that tax credits and financial assistance are available to help make their plans affordable … but it is going to be harder for people in certain parts of the state, especially, to find plans that fit their needs and are affordable to them.”

The Trump administration recently said in a fact sheet that Americans who shop for exchange plans on the federal exchange this open enrollment season will have “robust access to low-cost plans,” noting that more than 75% of shoppers will be able to buy plans for $50 a month or less. Illinois no longer uses the federal exchange, HealthCare.gov, and now runs its own at GetCovered.Illinois.gov.

Nationally, however, prices for mid-level plans are jumping by 13%, on average, according to KFF, a nonprofit organization focused on health policy.

In Illinois, many consumers are finding fewer choices when they shop for coverage for next year partly because two insurers – Cigna Healthcare and Molina Healthcare – are no longer offering exchange plans in Illinois after this year.

Conversely, residents of Cook County have between one and four additional plans available, because insurers Celtic Insurance Co., Oscar Health Plan and UnitedHealthcare of Illinois are offering more choices in that area, according to the Illinois Department of Insurance. The types of plans available vary by county.

Prices are also increasing in many cases.

For example, a 21-year-old, nonsmoker in Cook County will pay $322.60 a month for the lowest-cost bronze plan, before subsidies, next year, compared with $291.94 in 2026. That same young adult will pay $440.08 a month next year compared with $388.75 this year for the lowest-cost silver plan.

Higher metal level plans often cost more in premiums each month but have lower out-of-pocket costs for care.

“This enrollment season is so terrible,” said Alexandra Eidenberg, owner of Skokie-based insurance agency The Insurance People.

Prices for plans have been “astronomical,” she said. Plus, she said she’s seeing higher out-of-pocket maximums in many exchange plans for next year.

“We’ve literally been the bearer of bad news for weeks on end,” Eidenberg said.

Insurers have blamed the increases on rising medical costs and, in some cases, changes at the federal level that have led to fewer people paying for exchange plans.

At the end of 2025, enhanced subsidies that had helped to offset the monthly costs of exchange plans expired after Congress failed to reach a deal to extend those credits. The issue was at the heart of the government shutdown in 2025, which lasted more than a month.

Though subsidies are still available, fewer people now qualify for them, and those that do often get smaller amounts.

Gov. JB Pritzker, along with Sen. Tammy Duckworth and Lt. Gov. Juliana Stratton, who was recently elected to the Senate, have already called on the newly elected Congress to restore the more generous subsidies.

Waligora said she’s hopeful the new Congress will do just that, once they take their seats in January. Waligora is also a leader of Protect Our Care Illinois, a coalition of organizations working to defend Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act.

“I think enhanced premium tax credits have a very high likelihood of passage,” Waligora said. “Then the question becomes will the president sign or not?”

Restoring the enhanced subsidies will likely be a priority for the new Congress, said Cynthia Cox, a senior vice president and director of the program on the Affordable Care Act at KFF.

But she said consumers now in the midst of open enrollment season should make their choices based on the prices and options available now, rather than in anticipation of a potential change.

“If I were an ACA marketplace enrollee, I wouldn’t necessarily hang my hat on it,” Cox said of any potential change.

If the enhanced subsidies did come back next year, it’s possible they could be applied retroactively, meaning people could eventually get some money back for their plans for next year, such as when they file their taxes, Cox said.

Dafna Fink and her husband are hopeful for any kind of break. She said they’ve cut their budget but will likely have to go further into debt to pay for their health insurance for next year.

“We have to feed our family, we have to clothe our kids,” Dafna Fink said. “It’s just a hope and prayer every month.”

lschencker@chicagotribune.com