Daily Herald opinion: Why so mum on Fly Quiet: Residents, local leaders deserve answers on noise-reduction proposal
After extensive testing of a noise-reduction plan going as far back as 2005, suburban leaders and O’Hare International Airport planners have a pretty good idea of how an idea they submitted to the Federal Aviation Administration for approval four years ago will work.
“What we do know,” says Evan Summers, one of the architects of the newest Fly Quiet proposal, “is that the plan is safe, technically feasible, and effective.”
What they don’t know is what is stopping them from implementing it.
The O’Hare Noise Compatibility Commission approved a 12-week runway rotation plan in 2022, following testing that began in 2016. The rotation system was designed to provide periods of relief for residents in O’Hare takeoff and landing flight paths. It would replace the current voluntary program which encourages pilots and air traffic controllers to use designated runways during the late-evening and early morning hours.
And testing has generally supported the new arrangement. In a report on the situation Monday by our senior writer Marni Pyke, Chicago Department of Aviation Commissioner Michael McMurray emphasized the level of attention authorities have given this effort, adding in a letter to the FAA that tests show the system could be “successful in providing relief to communities most heavily impacted by noise,”
In 2024, state and federal officials produced a memorandum of understanding calling for the FAA to evaluate the proposal and conduct environmental impact studies. They have yet to receive a formal response.
The most that local leaders know now about the reason for the delay, according to ONCC Chair Joseph Annunzio, is that, “It is complex.”
Apparently, the complications involve questions about whether the environmental review is even necessary and whether two diagonal runways that are used only under certain conditions can be fit into the rotation.
If there are problems with the diagonal runways, the agency hasn’t specifically identified them, so planners cannot know how to revise their proposal. And, as Pyke reported, the Chicago Department of Aviation has asked the FAA to to respond in writing whether the environmental study is necessary. A year ago, McMurray went so far as to ask the agency to move forward and appoint someone to do it.
A spokesperson for the CDA told Pyke the department has “responded to all FAA requests regarding the proposed new Fly Quiet program,” yet still is waiting for direction.
Which brings us back to Summers, former chair of the ONCC’s Fly Quiet committee, with whose assessment we can only agree.
“First contemplated in 2005, and successfully tested a decade ago,” Summers told Pyke, “the fact that the FAA hasn’t implemented this plan is a disservice to the residents who suffer nighttime noise with no relief in sight. They deserve better.”
Indeed.
As do the agencies working locally to try to help them.