Judge challenges DOJ’s privilege claims in ‘Broadview Six’ case
A federal judge on Monday seemed deeply skeptical that information she’s demanded from prosecutors in the failed “Broadview Six” case would be privileged, telling a top Justice Department official she didn’t think he’d find any case law to back up their position.
The comments by U.S. District Judge April Perry came as Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the No. 3 official in the Justice Department, made his first court appearance in the case, where Perry is conducting an inquiry into allegations of prosecutorial misconduct.
Woodward, who took over the case just two weeks ago, has said in court filings that communications between the U.S. attorney’s office and DOJ about the Broadview case are largely off-limits to her investigation because of government privileges such as deliberative process and attorney work product.
In a filing late Sunday, Woodward said witnesses that Perry has ordered to testify under oath, including U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros, have all been instructed to assert those privileges and that to put them on the stand and “judicially cross-examine them” would pose an “intolerably high risk” of violating their rights.
But at a status hearing Monday, Perry said established case law generally shows privilege claims do not apply to fact-finding, and that deliberative process and attorney work product privileges only apply to conversations before a decision is made. Third-party statements made to her or anyone outside the government also do not apply, Perry said.
“I don’t intend to ask any questions that will call for a privileged answer,” Perry told the parties.
Woodward told the judge he’s concerned about Perry wearing “dual hats” in the process, which could let her see material that is later determined to be off-limits in making a ruling on sanctions or to appoint a special prosecutor. He said more research needed to be done on whether someone else should decide what is privileged in the case.
Perry said she’d be curious to know who would serve in that role, if not her.
“I would think … the appropriate decision-maker would be one of your colleagues, as opposed to you yourself” Woodward said.
Perry also said she was skeptical that there was any case law supporting Woodward’s position.
“I would love to see any case law on that if you can find it,” Perry said.
Woodward replied: “I don’t know that we will.”
“I don’t think you will either — but best of luck to you,” Perry said, smiling.
Perry ordered the four witnesses who have been ordered to testify — Boutros and line prosecutors William Hogan, Matthew Skiba, and Andres Almandarez — to email her written versions of any potentially privileged testimony by Friday. Responses from the government were due by Nov. 25.
For their part, attorneys for Hogan, Skiba and Almandarez all told the judge on Monday they don’t intend to individually assert any privileges. Attorney Shelly Kulwin, who represents Hogan, said the veteran prosecutor had nothing whatsoever to hide. “We both have more sunsets behind us that in front of us,” he said.
“He’s happy to fully explain his thought processes, who he talked to, who he didn’t,” Kulwin said. “He’s just going to say what happened. That’s not a problem.”
Boutros did not attend the hearing, and no private attorney has signed on to the case to represent him.
Woodward, who has drawn the ire of federal judges before, including in the fight over President Donald Trump’s plans to renovate a Washington, D.C., golf course, was polite in court Monday and there were no heated exchanges.
Still, his appearance has added another layer of intrigue in the long-running Broadview Six case, which was dismissed in May amid allegations of misconduct before the grand jury and an effort to hide it from the judge. Perry has scheduled a blockbuster Dec. 2 hearing where Boutros and his underlings are expected to testify about their actions both before and after the indictment was obtained.
Woodward has argued in recent court filings that Perry has put Boutros and his office in “a Catch-22” by ordering them to testify, and suggested the hearing should be called off entirely and let the Justice Department pursue its own internal investigation.
But Perry has so far shot down attempts by the Justice Department to limit or derail the proceedings, which could offer the spectacle of Boutros being ordered by his bosses in the attorney general’s office not to answer certain questions, or even with Chicago’s top federal law enforcement officer asserting his Fifth Amendment rights.
The Broadview Six indictment was one of the most serious cases brought against protesters during Operation Midway Blitz, the Trump administration’s aggressive deportation push last fall.
The felony charges alleged the six defendants — most of whom had ties to local Democratic politics — crowded around an ICE agent’s vehicle outside the Broadview ICE facility in September 2025, banged on the car and windows, and pushed against it to hinder and impede its movement.
Boutros was forced to drop all charges in May after it was revealed the lead prosecutor, Sheri Mecklenburg, had allegedly committed misconduct before the grand jury.
jmeisner@chicagotribune.com