Bracket breakdown: Semifinals bring classic matchups, plus teams trying to make history
The IHSA football playoffs have reached the semifinal round, with just four teams still standing in each class.
So let's just get right into breaking down the matchups featuring Chicago-area teams.
Class 8A
Oswego at Mount Carmel: This is a rematch of last year's title game, which the Caravan won 20-3. Mount Carmel is one of the most talented teams ever seen in Illinois, but Lincoln-Way East played a competitive game last weekend.
Can Oswego do the same? With running back Ammar Banire healthy again, the offense is balanced and the Panthers’ defense shut down Bolingbrook in the second half of their quarterfinal win. Maybe there's a chance, but Oswego needs just about everything to go right.
St. Ignatius at New Trier: New Trier lasting longer in the playoffs than neighborhood rival Loyola has happened in our lifetimes. In 2014, Loyola exited in the second round and the Trevians in the quarterfinals, with both losses coming against Stevenson.
Throy Nightingale rushed for 300 yards against Huntley, and 6-foot-5 quarterback Jackie Ryder is a Purdue commit. But don't sleep on New Trier's defense, which shut down the Red Raiders until the game was out of reach. The North Shore Hit Men will need to stand up to one of the most physical teams in the state in order to reach Normal.
St. Ignatius runs an option offense, but looks nothing like Barry Switzer-era Oklahoma. Basically, the plan is hand the rock to 5-foot-9 fullback Nino Capuano all day long. When the defense adjusts to stop him, they'll pitch it outside and get a long run. Junior quarterback Reid Hites is tough to bring down and ran for 88 yards against Loyola.
The Wolfpack got some big breaks against Loyola. A bad shotgun snap at the one-yard line turned a possible touchdown into a field goal. Then in the final minute of the second quarter, a St. Ignatius punt hit a Loyola player and was recovered by the Wolfpack, setting up the go-ahead touchdown.
St. Ignatius is the clear favorite here, but New Trier has played very well the past two weeks. This is the Trevians' first trip to the semis since 1982, the second year after merging back into a single school.
Class 7A
East St. Louis at Brother Rice: This one is tough to predict. The feeling here is Brother Rice has the best combination of size and talent in the trenches. But East St. Louis just rang up 65 points against a good Prospect team, and has playmakers all over the field.
Being at home will obviously be an advantage for the Crusaders. The fewest points ESL has scored against a team from Illinois is 35. Can Brother Rice win a 42-35 game? This one should be interesting.
Downers Grove North at Hersey: Luck of the draw sometimes produces the perfect matchup. This one feature's Hersey's powerful offense against the stingy defense of Downers Grove North.
The Huskies really do have everything. A nationally-ranked quarterback in Kentucky commit Jake Nawrot, multiple go-to receivers, a star running back in junior Jackson Travis, and a young, but effective offensive line. Hersey rarely punts, Nawrot is hardly ever sacked and he still hasn't thrown an interception this season.
DGN's run of not allowing more than 14 points in regulation time this season came to an end this weekend against Richards, but the outcome of that game was never really in doubt. The Trojans have some college-level talent on defense, but this unit is a classic mix of fast, physical, no weak spots and a solid scheme.
Something's got to give in this one, because DGN is not likely to win a shootout.
Class 6A
Fenwick at Harlem: Craziest comeback of the quarterfinals was turned in by the Harlem Huskies. They trailed 41-24 at the end of three quarters at Notre Dame, then rallied to win 45-41.
Harlem is 12-0 and the No. 1 seed in the top half of the bracket, but really should have lost its playoff opener to St. Charles East. The Huskies needed two late touchdowns to pull it out, while the Saints had four empty trips to the red zone.
The semifinals are uncharted territory not only for Harlem, but the full community. It's probably fair to call Harlem a Rockford school, even though it's in a suburb. From that group of Rockford public schools, the most recent semifinal appearance was by Rockford West (which no longer exists) in 1988. Harlem had played just one quarterfinal game before last weekend (in 2022).
Meanwhile, Fenwick brings a physical defense to the field, but its greatest asset is slugger Jake Thies. The Iowa commit is a true home-run hitter who can go the distance on any touch. His 55-yard touchdown run was the difference in a 14-7 win over Wheaton North on Saturday.
What this game needs most is for Cheap Trick vocalist and Harlem grad Robin Zander to sing the anthem before kickoff. This is true Rockford history.
Nazareth at Wheaton Warrenville South: Health will be important to this matchup. WWS is loaded with juniors and has gotten better each week, but quarterback A.J. Rogers left the quarterfinal win over Normal West with an injury. His availability will be vital.
Nazareth got defensive end Chris Kasky, a Missouri commit, back from an injury for the win over Quincy, while safety Henry Sakalas, a Michigan State commit, was still sidelined.
Class 5A
Sycamore at Cary-Grove: This is a battle of two teams that finished third in their conferences this season. Cary-Grove has as much recent playoff experience as any school, so the Trojans are right where they belong. They forced four turnovers while beating defending 5A champ St. Francis last weekend.
Cary-Grove seems to have the much better resume, especially the win over St. Francis. Don't be fooled by the Spartans' 4-5 record in the regular season.
Mahomet Seymour at Providence: This is one of those matchups that's tough to judge until the teams actually collide. It's been a magical season for Mahomet Seymour. The Champaign-area school is 12-0 with an average margin of victory of 32.8 points.
Will that help against Providence? The Celtics survived a rough schedule, the firing of their head coach and are looking to flip last year's title game loss. This is a classic “upstart vs. powerhouse” story.
Class 4A
Morris at Coal City: This is a rematch from Week 2 when Morris won 28-7. The Warriors seemed to clinch a spot in the state title game by beating Montini last week. Then again, we've seen Loyola, Bolingbrook and Geneva all lose to teams they beat during the regular season, so no guarantees.
Class 3A
Richmond-Burton at IC Catholic Prep: Richmond-Burton is undefeated and beat IC Prep on the way to a 2019 state title in 4A. But no team in this 3A field can match the Knights' talent, even if IC Prep continues to use a backup quarterback.
Class 2A
Wilmington at Aurora Christian: Another stunning comeback from last weekend was by Aurora Christian, which trailed El Paso-Gridley 24-7 at one point, before a pair of touchdown passes by sophomore quarterback Juju Vasquez in the final two minutes settled a 28-24 victory.
Wilmington's lone loss was 14-0 to Coal City, a team that's still playing. Based on their one common opponent, Wilmington has the edge since it beat Bishop McNamara 16-7 in Week 1. Aurora Christian lost to the Irish 42-22 in Week 5.