‘Hard to make it worse’: East Dundee cocktail bar pairs Malört with beer
When the father-and-son team behind The Distance Social in East Dundee decided to make a Malört barrel-infused beer, they knew they had at least one thing going for them when working with the much-maligned bitter liqueur.
“Hard to make it worse,” Joey Zeller said.
The second annual iteration of Truth ör Dare, a malt liquor aged in used Malört barrels for seven months, will be unleashed on the public Wednesday, Nov. 18, with a launch party at the craft cocktail and whiskey lounge at 314 N. River St.
Last year’s release of 300 bottles sold out in less than six weeks.
“It was a huge hit,” said Joe Zeller, the elder of the two. “We call it the ‘East Dundee handshake.’ We had people drive from two states over last year to get it. It’s weird.”
The pairing is based on the well-known “Chicago handshake” order of a shot of Malört and an Old Style beer chaser.
The 20-ounce bottles cost $14 each, 3 for $36 or $100 for a 12-pack. If you’re drinking it on premises, you can add a shot of Malört for a buck or bourbon for $2.
For a bar that prides itself on elevated cocktails, the question one must ask is ‘Why?’. Why would you pair a liqueur known for slogans like “it’s what soap washes its mouth out with” and “tonight’s the night you fight your dad,” with a beer associated with drinking out of paper bag-wrapped cans under railroad bridges?
“I would argue even though it seems lowbrow, it's kind of cool,” Joey Zeller said. “The bitterness of the Malört balances out the sweetness of the malt liquor that comes from the lack of hops.”
His dad, Joe, said people are “infatuated” with Malört.
“Maybe that’s not the right word, but it’s just iconic,” he said.
“It's not as bad as people make it out to be,” Joey Zeller added.
The beer isn’t the bar’s only playful dalliance with Malört. They’re constantly making “mystery” infusions to see what other new, weird flavor combinations they can come up with.
“Cantaloupe was good, fennel was good. Aniseed was bad,” Joey Zeller said. “We’ve done infusions with Ramen packets, matcha tea. People enjoy trying to guess what it is.”
The Zellers collaborated with the since-shuttered Black & Gray Brewing Co. to make Truth ör Dare for the past two years. The brewpub that was located up the street closed in October.
“This is sort of their last call,” Joe Zeller said of the brewery.
Joey Zeller said if they sell out this batch, which they doubled in size to 600 bottles, they’ll find another brewery with which to partner.
“If it’s as popular as it was last year, we'll do it again next year,” he said. “Finding someone to brew it won't be an issue.”
The Zellers agree that this batch turned out smoother than last year’s.
“It’s more well-rounded, for sure,” Joey Zeller said. “It tastes more like the lingering aftertaste of the Chicago handshake than the other one did.”
Jeppson’s Malört reps will be on hand for the release party, which starts at 6 p.m. and will include merchandise giveaways and guests can give the Malört Wheel of Doom a spin for prizes (or ostensibly punishments if drinking Malört is involved).
Joe Zeller said people told him they gave bottles purchased last year as white elephant or gag gifts. He thinks you’re missing out if you don’t try it yourself.
“I’m telling you, it's better than it sounds,” he said.
rwest@dailyherald.com