advertisement

What does College Football Playoff expansion mean for local teams and fans? It depends on your situation.

The College Football Playoff announced its long-debated expansion to 24 teams in 2027 in a deal that broadcast partner ESPN reported is worth an additional $1.7 billion over five years.

The expansion, largely driven by Big Ten leaders, dramatically changes the postseason landscape after just three years of a 12-team playoff.

What does it mean for area teams and their coaches and fan bases? Here’s a look at some of the major questions that arise with the new deal.

How do local coaches feel about the expansion?

Many Power Four conference coaches had expressed support for expansion for obvious reasons. More playoff spots means more opportunities for their teams to secure a coveted place in the postseason.

A cynical observer might note that means more opportunities for those coaches to earn playoff bonuses — and job security. A more generous critic might note that means a better chance for their players and fans to experience the thrill of a postseason game.

Either way, count Notre Dame’s Marcus Freeman, Illinois’ Bret Bielema and Northwestern’s David Braun as public supporters of the expansion.

“I don’t want this to be like March Madness and have 60-something teams making the playoffs,” Freeman said at his Monday news conference. “But the more opportunities we have to make the playoffs helps us. It helps us in scheduling. It helps if there happens to be a defeat, you’ve still got more opportunities to make the playoffs.

“It’s good for us. That doesn’t mean it’s good for everybody else, but for us at Notre Dame, it’s a positive.”

In the new format, the Power Four champions and the top-ranked Group of Six team will automatically qualify, with 19 at-large bids chosen by the CFP selection committee. Braun said the larger field allows teams playing their best football late in the year a chance to prove they’re national title contenders.

“There’s all sorts of parity across college football right now,” he said, “and the expanded playoff allows for a lot of these conversations to be handled where they should be handled, and that’s not in the court of public opinion or in the media. It’s on the football field.”

What is the effect on the regular season?

The new format comes with scheduling rules. Every Power Four team and Notre Dame will have to schedule at least 10 games against other Power Four teams or Notre Dame, and only one game against an FCS team will be given weight by the committee.

The Big Ten already plays nine conference games, so that rule isn’t too big of a change for those programs. But Big Ten Commissioner Tony Petitti has argued that nonconference scheduling will become more competitive because teams will be less wary of suffering a single loss.

Bielema echoed that argument Monday, pointing to the Illini’s recent addition of a Notre Dame series.

“I know that some of the talking heads out there have been talking about how it’s going to lessen the effect of the season,” Bielema said. “I think it’s the exact opposite. It’s going to only enhance everything.

“Obviously we’re playing Notre Dame in a back-to-back home-game schedule (starting in 2027), which is just incredibly awesome. I don’t think that happens without this policy.”

How expansion will affect the meaning of regular-season games, though, is under heavy debate.

For example, Notre Dame’s game against then-No. 1 Miami on Saturday, which the Irish won 31-24, was looked at as a must-win for a CFP berth because of the Irish’s one loss and overall strength of schedule. With the expanded playoff, it likely wouldn’t have had such a critical feel.

But Northwestern’s loss to Iowa and Illinois’ win over Nebraska over the weekend might have had higher stakes with a 24-team field because those teams sit in the second tier of the Big Ten, which could benefit from expansion. In the first CFP rankings, three Big Ten teams (No. 4 Indiana, No. 8 UCLA and No. 12 Ohio State) were in the top 12, and three more (No. 19 Iowa, No. 20 USC and No. 23 Oregon) were in the top 24.

Last month during Big Ten basketball media days, Petitti argued that elevating the meaning of such games was the point of expansion — beyond the unspoken benefit of additional money.

“The definition of success in college football is qualifying for the CFP,” he said. “That’s where you start, and then you hope that you’re the last team left and you win.

“What we are focused on is giving more programs a chance to have that level of success. … We’ve got a lot of teams that, if they were thinking about 24 right now, the amount of teams that are alive and playing (critical) games right now would be even greater.”

How should fans feel about the expansion?

The answer probably falls under what type of college football fan you are.

Are you a fan of a blue-blood team that spends $40 million to $50 million on its roster and rarely falls out of the Top 25? Expansion probably feels pretty pointless to you. With that budget, your team should have been competing for a spot in a 12-team field every year, and if not, there was always the next year after buying other teams’ best players in the transfer portal.

Are you a general college football fan who is worried about the importance of the biggest games being watered down? It’s a fair concern when three- and possibly even four-loss teams could get in, though Petitti has argued that seeding incentives will boost the importance of some late-season games.

The top eight seeds will get a first-round bye and host a second-round game. Seeds 9-16 will host first-round games.

Are you a fan of a middle-tier program that is pretty good but doesn’t quite have the high-paid talent to get into CFP consideration yearly? Don’t be ashamed. There are a lot of you. And this probably will add some excitement to your season.

Northwestern and Illinois, which never have made the CFP, still would be squarely in the mix for a playoff spot under the 24-team format with three games to play this season. And a playoff game, with a chance to keep the season going, carries a potentially better reward than a random bowl game.

But it all remains to be seen. CFP executive director Rich Clark told reporters that playoff officials understand fans’ feelings about expansion.

“We’re aware of the fan sentiment and that many fans aren’t in favor of expansion,” he said. “That was certainly weighed into the decision and it was considered. But ultimately, we just need to make a spectacular playoff. The CFP has a responsibility to our fans. They’re the lifeblood of college football, and we owe it to them to make this great and that really is our intent.”

What about the Group of Six teams?

The highest-ranked team from the American, Conference USA, Mid-American, Mountain West, Pac-12 or Sun Belt conferences will receive an automatic bid into the playoff.

Beyond that, it’s up to the selection committee to determine whether more Group of Six teams are worthy compared with the second wave of Power Four teams.

MAC Commissioner Jon Steinbrecher released a statement Monday saying the conference has long advocated for greater access to the CFP and is pleased to be a part of the 24-team playoff. But he went on to ask whether expansion is good for the sport as a whole.

“One of the great attributes of college football is the significance of its regular season,” he said in the statement. “Every game matters. Rivalries matter. Conference championships matter. As we expand the postseason, we must be careful not to diminish the very qualities that have made college football such a compelling sport.

“We must also recognize that a larger playoff does not necessarily mean greater financial benefits for all conferences and institutions, making the long-term sustainability of the entire FBS an important consideration.”

The Mountain West, in which Northern Illinois now competes in football, released a statement Tuesday that said more opportunities to compete for a national championship is a positive. But the conference also noted that its teams need access to high-level regular-season games to build their playoff cases.

“Meaningful nonconference competition against automatic-qualifying conferences and other quality opponents becomes more important than ever,” the statement said. “Access to these matchups not only benefits the FBS ecosystem, but also enhances the strength, visibility and credibility of deserving programs.”

What happens to the conference championship games?

Shortly after the CFP expansion announcement, the Power Four conferences all announced the end of their championship games.

For the Big Ten, that means the Dec. 5 game in Indianapolis will be the 16th and final conference championship game. In a statement, Petitti thanked the city of Indianapolis and its supporters for making the game “a marquee event each season since its inception in 2011.”

Northwestern has made two Big Ten championship game appearances, in 2018 and 2020, both losses to Ohio State. Illinois never has made a conference title game.

Ohio State leads with seven appearances and five wins.