Watchdogs question legitimacy of new campaign donation rules
In the wake of Gov. Rod Blagojevich's ouster, Illinois lawmakers passed this year the first-ever limits on campaign donations, bringing the corruption-plagued state apparently in line with most of the nation.
But watchdog groups say that in the long Illinois tradition of passing fake reform measures, the new limits are another sham and they find themselves in the odd position of lobbying Gov. Pat Quinn - himself a veteran ethics advocate - to veto or rewrite campaign donation limits they have long sought.
"This is just fatally flawed," said Dave Lundy, president of the Better Government Association, which is lobbying Quinn with other organizations.
Vetoing or rewriting the measure would run the risk that lawmakers won't approve the changes or pass any other limits down the road. Some reformers are willing to take that risk.
"These limits are worse than having no limits," added David Morrison, deputy director of the Illinois Campaign for Political Reform. "The problems are so extensive the risk is that lawmakers would not get around to fixing them if this became law."
Representatives from watchdog groups have been in touch with Quinn's staff and key lawmakers over the last several weeks. They remain hopeful Quinn will end up vetoing the legislation or rewriting and sending it back to lawmakers for another vote.
Quinn has until the end of the month to make up his mind or the legislation becomes law even without his signature.
For his part, Quinn backed the criticized campaign finance limits, praising them as a tremendous step forward for Illinois politics. He even went against his own blue-ribbon reform commission to support the final package, calling it a just compromise with lawmakers loath to approve any limits.
Yet, from the start, it was clear the legislation was not what good government groups thought would make a difference in Illinois' high-priced campaigns. For one, the limits themselves are twice that of those for the president and Congress.
If signed into law, candidates would be limited to taking $5,000 from one person or $10,000 from one entity, such as a union or business, every year. Federal limits are $2,400 and $5,000 respectively, per election cycle.
Other problems include the ability of multi-candidate committees to funnel up to $90,000 to campaigns and a complete abolition of limits in races where candidates use more than $250,000 of their own cash.
Still, the current system is wide open. Donors can give as much as they want to any candidate as long as it is made public in semiannual and pre-election reports. The only ban is on the governor, who can't take donations from state contractors.
Good-government groups fear the new limits, however, will give a veneer of reform that will cover up business as usual.
"This is a step sideways. This is not reform," says Jim Bray, spokesman for the CHANGE Illinois! organization working with the BGA and ICPR. "A lot more work needs to be done."
There are signs Quinn may veto or rewrite the limits. In recent news conferences, he hasn't committed to signing the legislation even if he had praised it upon passage this spring.
"I'm going to be talking to everybody," he said. "I plan for the rest of this month to be listening and we ultimately will do something with that bill."
Quinn continues to agree voters should take heart that limits were approved at all even if good government groups view them as a cover.
"I do think it is important that for the first time in the history of Illinois ... that the legislature did pass limits," Quinn said. "We should not diminish that."
<p class="factboxtextbold12col"><b>Reform loopholes</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">Here is a look at what watchdog groups consider to be loopholes in Illinois' first campaign contribution limits:</p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col"><b>Big Money</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">• Reformers were hoping for federal limits, which are $2,400 per person and $5,000 per political organization. Illinois' new limits are at least double that.</p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">J<b>ust More Checks</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">• The donation caps apply to calender years, not election cycles. So, a lawmaker could collect $10,000 from a group every year in office, not just once for the primary and once for the general election. That is a difference between $40,000 from one group for a four-year office holder and $20,000 if the limit were by election cycle. This also puts incumbents at a distinct advantage.</p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col"><b>Funneling Cash</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">• The law allows multicandidate committees to donate up to $90,000 to an individual candidate. This means a candidate could get $90,000 from multiple party committees, each of which would be able to obtain $5,000 or $10,000 contributions from the same people or entities.</p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col"><b>Trashing Limits</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">• For all candidates in a race who donate more than $250,000 of their own money to their own campaigns, even if it is as a loan, limits for those candidates and their competitors are automatically tossed aside. Some say this would allow even middle-class candidates to, for instance, take out a mortgage on their home and temporarily put the money in their campaign to avoid limits. </p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col"><b>No Enforcement</b></p> <p class="factboxtextbold12col">• No additional money has been set aside for regulators to monitor and enforce the new law. Plus, the board was given few new powers to do so anyway. Current penalties and oversight are already considered weak for the very limited rules in place. </p>