What are the differences between a patient advocate and a life care manager?
A recent article described an emerging health care-related field that helps seniors and their families navigate the trials and tribulations that come with aging: the life care manager.
“What distinguishes her (it is usually a woman) from people with confusingly similar names — senior care advisers, patient advocates, care navigators — is her independence,” the author, Paula Span, wrote.
As an independent patient advocate, I know that sentence to be misleading. Yes, there are patient advocates who work for hospitals and insurance companies, but they are being paid to keep their employers from being sued and maximize profits.
I thought it would be useful to compare and contrast the roles of the independent patient advocate and aging life care manager. Which one you or your aging loved one needs depends on the situation, and they could even complement each other.
How are they alike?
Independence is one obvious similarity. Both life care managers and independent patient advocates are employed by the client or the family and are not beholden to any hospital, medical practice, insurance company or care facility.
This is an important distinction, because you might be researching nursing homes for an aging parent only to find out that the person helping you gets a commission for recommending a particular facility.
Both types of professionals charge fees to their clients, usually on an hourly basis, with huge variations depending on the market.
A patient advocate and a life care manager may also perform similar tasks, such as coordinating doctor’s appointments, connecting with community resources, recommending elder law attorneys and keeping tabs on a client whose family doesn’t live nearby. They can also act as a sounding board or a bridge among family members who may not agree on care.
An important similarity is certification. An independent patient advocate like myself will usually have a BCPA after their name: Board-Certified Patient Advocate, a designation by the Patient Advocate Certification Board (pacboard.org/). After advanced education and supervised experience, life care managers can be certified by the Aging Life Care Association (aginglifecare.org/). Ask about certification if you’re considering hiring one of these professionals.
Both would also need to legal permission from clients to speak with clinicians about their care.
How are they different?
A life care manager may come from a medical background, but they could just as likely start as a social worker or gerontologist, someone who studies aging. A patient advocate, particularly one who is called into a situation during a hospitalization, usually comes with a background in nursing or another medical field. As a registered nurse, my mission in life is recruiting and training nurses to become nurse-advocate entrepreneurs.
That medical knowledge lets the patient advocate review test results, ask detailed questions of the care team, suggest follow-up tests, coordinate specialists, go to doctor’s appointments, and then translate medical jargon for the patient and their family. The patient advocate can also review hospital bills for errors and go toe-to-toe with insurance companies over claims.
Where they work, I think, is a difference. A patient advocate is more likely to start working with a client in a hospital setting, when families become concerned about a loved one’s care. A life care manager is more likely to come on the scene later.
One thing you can count on: A good patient advocate or life care manager will be there when you need them, whether you are the client or the family member of a client. They will know what to do when you don’t, and they will always make you their top priority.
• Teri (Dreher) Frykenberg is a registered nurse and board-certified patient advocate. She is the author of several books on advocacy and founder of Nurse Advocate Entrepreneur, which equips medical professionals with the knowledge and skills to start their own advocacy businesses. Contact her at Teri@NurseAdvocateEntrepreneur.com.