advertisement

Where do the wealthy fit in to government budgeting

When Americans are asked if the rich should pay higher taxes, the answer is consistently yes, though – not surprisingly – there is a partisan divide.

Gallup found that about 63% favor higher taxes on high earners and large corporations. That breaks down by party – 86% of Democrats, 62% of independents, and 38% of Republicans, who, as a rule, favor lower taxes.

So, on Election Day when Californians were asked if there should be a one-time 5% levy on residents and trusts with at least $1 billion in assets to support health care, education, and food assistance Californians said no.

What gives? California is predominantly blue.

In reaction to measures in the One Big Beautiful Bill that would reduce funding for health care in America, a healthcare workers union gathered the signatures to put the measure on the ballot. The union origin generated some opposition.

As you can imagine, wealthy Californians fought passage tooth and nail. Sergey Brin, one of the co-founders of Google, spent tens of millions opposing the proposition. Several tech billionaires either shifted their residences to other states or threatened to do so, including Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg.

An analysis by the State of California found that as a result, the levy would – in the long run – reduce state revenues. That caused many prominent Democrats, including Gov. Gavin Newsom, to oppose the measure.

We live at a time when numerous individuals have amassed great fortunes. Elon Musk is the poster child. His net worth briefly hit $1 trillion (one million seconds tick by in 11.6 days, a trillion seconds takes 31,710 years).

However, Musk did not accept a salary from Tesla or SpaceEx (causing California to go after him for violating minimum wage laws – ha!). Amazon founder Jeff Bezos took a salary of $1. Their wealth – like many mega-wealthy individuals – is in their ownership of stock and other assets, which is taxed at lower rates or, often, not at all.

In her 2024 book The Second Estate, Professor Ray Madoff argues that America’s tax laws allow people of great wealth (as opposed to high-salaried individuals) to pay little or no taxes on their growing fortunes. (The Second Estate was made up of nobles in pre-revolutionary France, who, because of their exalted positions, paid no taxes.)

High-salaried individuals (doctors, lawyers, professional athletes) pay higher taxes and, yes, the top 1% of earners pay 40% of all income taxes. And, yes, the bottom 40% of Americans pay no income taxes. That said, everyone pays the payroll taxes that support Social Security and Medicare.

Madoff argues that our founders felt that large concentrations of wealth went against the grain of the egalitarian ethos of America. Historically, politicians were willing to raise taxes on the wealthy in reaction to rising populist/socialist movements. Those tax increases were meant to protect capitalism.

We are seeing some of those stirrings today. When Musk pumped millions into the Texas senate race, Sen.-elect James Talarico effectively counter-punched, arguing billionaires were trying to “buy” the election. At least six Democratic Socialist candidates were elected to the House. Bernie Sanders still draws big crowds. Socialists are mayors of New York and L.A.

That said, government involvement in the economy (socialism) has – ironically – grown sharply under the current Republican president and Congress.

Madoff’s proposal to make the system fairer (and there are many others) is to tax all income the same and reinvigorate the estate tax – which has been rendered largely meaningless by a well-orchestrated campaign calling it the “death tax.”

Our economy is growing and yet we are running $2 trillion annual deficits and Social Security and Medicare are on the doorstep of insolvency. Something has got to give.

• Keith Peterson, of Lake Barrington, served 29 years as a press and cultural officer for the United States Information Agency and Department of State. He was chief editorial writer of the Daily Herald 1984-86. His book “American Dreams: The Story of the Cyprus Fulbright Commission” is available from Amazon.com.