Homebuyer in panic over asbestos ceiling
Q: According to my home inspector, the popcorn ceilings in the home I'm buying probably contain at least about 3% asbestos. He said this is not a problem, but I'm very concerned and am trying to absorb this news without letting it depress me. How do I reassure myself that these ceilings are safe? I have two young sons who are active! What if they throw balls and things against the ceilings? What if they stand on their bunk bed and scrape the ceiling? How can I live with the knowledge that all this asbestos is hanging over our heads?
A: Anxiety over residential asbestos is very common, given the many scary articles that have been published over the years. However, asbestos panic is inconsistent with the actual level of risk posed by asbestos-containing building materials such as acoustic “popcorn" ceilings.
All of the studies that connect asbestos exposure with lung disease involve people who have worked with asbestos in full-time professions, either manufacturing or installing asbestos products. It has never been proven that low-level exposures cause health problems for occupants of a home. Fear and worry over asbestos-containing materials in a home are therefore unwarranted.
Levels of 1% to 3% of asbestos are often found in acoustic ceilings installed prior to 1980 and in some homes built through the mid-1980s.
Fortunately, the asbestos fibers in popcorn ceilings are not released unless the material is disturbed. One way to decrease the likelihood of fiber release is to have the ceilings thoroughly spray-painted. Paint seals the particles that comprise the textured surface, fusing them into a solidified crust that is much less likely to crumble when touched, scraped or impacted by indoor ball playing or by romping on the upper bunk.
Additionally, there are many acoustic ceilings that do not contain asbestos, and home inspectors should not make definitive statements about asbestos content unless a written report from an asbestos test lab is available. To specify that a ceiling may contain a particular amount of asbestos, without a report to substantiate that disclosure, is professionally inappropriate for a home inspector.
Before assuming that the ceilings in a particular home contain asbestos, send three random samples of the material to an EPA certified lab for testing. If the results are positive and you decide to remove the ceiling texture, contact a licensed asbestos abatement contractor for a bid.
In recent years, many homeowners have had acoustic ceilings removed, not because of concern over asbestos safety, but for purposes of cosmetic update. When confronted with the high cost of asbestos removal, some homeowners have opted to cover the ceilings with a second layer of drywall. However, those who take this approach should be aware that disclosure will be necessary when the home is eventually sold. Otherwise, an unsuspecting future owner could contaminate the interior of the home when demolishing a ceiling that contains concealed asbestos.
For further information regarding residential asbestos, check the website of the Consumer Products Safety Commission (cpsc.gov).
• Distributed by Action Coast Publishing. Questions to Barry Stone can be emailed to barry@housedetective.com.