Review: Vibrant new portrait of artist Helen Frankenthaler

'œFierce Poise: Helen Frankenthaler and 1950s New York,'ť by Alexander Nemerov (Penguin Press)

There are doorstop biographies, and then there are appreciations. Alexander Nemerov has taken the latter approach in 'œFierce Poise,'ť his vibrant, sympathetic portrait of Helen Frankenthaler. It focuses on 11 consequential days in the 1950s, the decade when she came of age as one of the leading painters of her generation.

Nemerov, the son of the celebrated poet Howard Nemerov and nephew of photographer Diane Arbus, grew up in the same rarified world as Frankenthaler. He admired her art for years but didn't feel prepared to write her biography until he got older (he's 57) and gave himself permission to love her 'œpretty'ť art, pictures that portray 'œfleeting impressions'ť through 'œblots and swaths of bright color'ť poured and stained into canvas, 'œas surprising and glorious as life itself.'ť

'œThe prevailing ways of seeing art over the past 50 years have made it difficult to comprehend the strength and sober delight of her kind of painting,'ť he writes. 'œOur culture has become terribly skeptical of romantic art such as hers.'ť

It's good he finally undertook the project because Frankenthaler, one of the five women artists profiled in Mary Gabriel's highly regarded 2018 'œNinth Street Women,'ť is a fascinating subject. He touches on her privileged life growing up on Manhattan's Upper East Side; her life-changing encounter with Jackson Pollock's drip paintings; the stormy love affair with the influential, older art critic Clement Greenberg; a later marriage to fellow abstract expressionist painter Robert Motherwell; and the creation of her breakthrough painting, 'œMountains and Sea,'ť in 1952.

An art historian at Stanford, Nemerov is a thoughtful and judicious writer. He does a good job of sorting through various criticisms leveled at Frankenthaler over the years, including that she was an opportunist, coasted by on family wealth, and was too elitist and apolitical.

Some readers may wish he had delved more deeply into the entire body of work - she died in 2011 at age 83 - and more fully addressed the bizarre criticism, scarcely rebutted here, that her signature stain technique was related to menstruation. Indeed, Joan Mitchell - another of the 'œNinth Street Women'ť - called her 'œthat Kotex painter.'ť

But brevity can be a virtue. In just over 200 pages, Nemerov takes us on a fast, exhilarating ride through the formative decade of her career, providing a lucid introduction to an artist we're likely to hear more about in the near future. A year after Gabriel's book came out, Amy Sherman-Palladino and Dan Palladino, creators of 'œThe Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,'ť announced they hoped to develop it for a new series.


Ann Levin worked for The Associated Press for 20 years, including as national news editor at AP headquarters in New York. Since 2009 she's worked as a freelance writer and editor.

Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the "flag" link in the lower-right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.