Lawsuit against Cook Co. Tax Appeal board tossed
A federal lawsuit filed by Cook County political insider Victor Santana against the county's tax appeal board has been tossed out.
U.S. District Judge Milton Shadur determined Santana's lawsuit, which alleges he was made a "scapegoat" in a brewing corruption scandal, was improperly written and in some cases appeared to lack merit.
"Neither the defense counsel nor this court may fairly be required to cope with such an obviously noncompliant pleading," penned Shadur of Santana's 70-page lawsuit that alleges everything from conspiracy to constitutional violations.
The lawsuit was filed by Santana against the Cook County Board of Review for banning him from the private office areas and allegedly implying to the media that he was part of a scandal over fixing property tax appeals.
The scandal started with accusations that state Rep. Paul Froehlich was trading campaign cash for help appealing property taxes. Froehlich and Santana have denied any wrongdoing.
Santana, a political consultant, is a former aide to veteran Board of Review Commissioner Joseph Berrios, who is running for county assessor and is a lobbyist who pushed the legalization of video poker through the General Assembly earlier this year.
In his dismissal of the suit on Tuesday, Shadur also raised questions about what grounds Santana can stand on in arguing he should have access to private areas used by the review board. Santana is not a board of review employee.
"In light of the foregoing, any claim of deprivation of liberty or property without due process ... would appear to be questionable at best," Shadur wrote.
Shadur also wrote that other elements of Santana's suit "seem problematic" and "appear to lack merit."
Santana is allowed to refile his lawsuit by Aug. 31. A call to Santana's attorney was not returned Thursday.