advertisement

Trade group battles over geographical names

As most of the world surrendered to the slow, humid descent into late July last week, when the effort required to last through the workday without nodding off for a few moments began to seem monumental as opposed to minimal, delegates from 153 countries convened at the World Trade Organization for a seemingly endless stretch of early mornings, late nights, indecipherable jargon, and heated international discourse. The ongoing negotiations, which collapsed for the seventh time in as many years on Tuesday evening, were originally convened in Doha, Qatar, and are meant to address the opportunities that might be created for developing markets by increased access to international trading opportunities.

It gets slightly more complicated after that.

Ministers and spokespeople struggling for adjectives relied heavily on analogies to explain the events of the week, at different times likening the talks to an excursion to the summit of Mont Blanc (WTO Director General Paschal Lamy) and constructing a cathedral (European Union Commissioner Peter Mandelson). At other times the agreement under debate was compared to a garment - "You pull one thread," said US Trade Representative Susan Schwab, "and it threatens to unravel the only path to success that we've had to this point" - and a snowball - WTO spokesman Keith Rockwell instructed members of the press to "Think of this as a snowball going down the hill; that snowball's getting mighty big."

The agreement members had hoped to reach was both complex and fragile, within the delicate balance of which swung the economies of developing countries, the continuation of the ongoing food and energy crises, international economic stability, the livelihoods of small farmers and hundreds of thousands of jobs around the world.

But let's not forget champagne.

Buried deep within the complex and overwhelming volume of documents that are the basis for the failed negotiations are a little thing referred to in trade circles as "TRIPS": Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights. A number of different issues fall under TRIPS. One of them, called geographical indications, is a small clause which, before the talks' demise, threatened to cause big problems.

"Geographical indications," states the World Trade Organization, "are place names (in some countries also words associated with a place) used to identify products that come from these places and have specific characteristics."

Examples would be products such as "Florida oranges," "Parmesan cheese," and "Idaho potatoes." Champagne, as we know it, comes only from the Champagne region of France - everything else is sparkling white wine.

The WTO states that geographical indications are necessary in order to "avoid misleading the public and to prevent unfair competition." It's a brief explanation within an immense infrastructure of documents, but one that certain parties, even after the collapse, are continuing to take extremely seriously, and which could have had a significant impact on the overall outcome of negotiations.

When the European Union unveiled their proposal - reduction in the high import tariffs that have historically protected their farmers from foreign competition - they made it abundantly clear that what they expected in return was protection of the things they hold sacred.

"As concerns the EU," said President of the European Union Council of Ministers Anne-Marie Idrac, "progress with regard to geographical indications are a must."

"When I said earlier," she continued, "that we would like to demonstrate our willingness, a global willingness, in these discussions, that means we want geographical indications included in there."

One might point out that arguing about whether Roquefort by any other name would taste as smoky while cotton farmers across India are committing suicide in the face of insurmountable loan payments and fishermen in Latin America fear the immanent depletion of the resources that provide for the existence of their industry seems at best insensitive and at worst incomprehensible.

But to chalk the issue up to a more technical iteration of "What's in a name?" is to oversimplify. Among the go-to catchphrases of ministers at the conference is "livelihood protection," and many have argued that stronger defense for geographical indicators would help preserve traditional occupations in developed countries, struggling to survive against corporate competitors, as well as providing increased opportunities for producers in developing markets.

Ultimately dissent over something known as the "special safeguard mechanism" prevented negotiators from ever tackling the issue of geographical indications head on. With talks suspended until further notice, the issue remains unresolved, a potential deal breaker for future delegations to grapple with.

"Remember gentlemen," Winston Churchill once famously told fellow leaders, "it's not just France we are fighting for, it's Champagne!"

At the World Trade Organization, it would seem the battle continues.