China blames U.S. toy designers
BEIJING -- Faulty American designs and conflicting global standards for safety are at the root of the mass recalls of Chinese-made toys by Mattel Inc., a top Chinese quality official said Monday.
Defending the overall quality of Chinese workmanship, Li Changjiang, director of the General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine, said recent export problems stemmed from "different standards that China and the United States apply to different products."
"That would lead to difficulty in defining whether a product is problematic," Li added at a news conference without elaborating.
His comments were the latest in China's effort to show it is striving to overcome safety woes and is a trustworthy manufacturer. But continuing discoveries of high levels of chemicals and toxins in Chinese goods -- from toothpaste and clothes to fish and juice -- are making that an uphill task.
This month, Mattel, the world's largest toy maker, recalled almost 19 million Chinese-made dolls, cars and action figures because they were contaminated with lead paint or contained small, powerful magnets that could damage a child's organs if swallowed.
"About 85 percent were directly designed by the American company and produced according to requirements of the American importer," Li said of the toys.
"I personally have seen some of the toys. There are serious problems in their design, so they are highly dangerous for children. These types of toys would be recalled in any country."
He did not give details on the alleged design problems.
Li conceded Chinese producers also have responsibility for making problematic toys, but asked "what kind of responsibility should the U.S. importers and U.S. designers take in this respect?"
Chinese officials said last week that 18.2 million of the recalled toys -- including Polly Pocket dolls and Barbie play sets -- were pulled off the shelves because of international standards for magnets were revised in May.
Mattel first announced a recall targeting magnets last November, after several Polly Pocket-related injuries were reported. It extended that recall to conform to the new standards, which require safety warnings for toys with magnets or magnetic components not attached tightly.
At the same time, the company recalled 436,000 "Sarge" cars based on the character from the movie "Cars" because they contained lead paint.
Li said that Chinese-made toys are safe for the most part, saying the number of recalled toys was a tiny fraction of the 22 billion toys exported from China last year.