SPRINGFIELD -- The Illinois Senate Wednesday approved a plan to cut working teachers' pensions while rejecting a more sweeping plan, sending mixed messages about where the debate over one of the state's biggest financial problems will go next.
A plan by state Sen. Daniel Biss to cut the pensions of public employees including teachers and lawmakers, which had appeared to gain bipartisan momentum in recent months, was instead soundly defeated 30-23.
How suburban lawmakers votedOn a smaller teachers pension bill
How suburban lawmakers voted on a bill to cut working teachers' future retirement benefits, which passed 30-22 in the Illinois Senate.
Melinda Bush, Grayslake Democrat; Tom Cullerton, Villa Park Democrat; Don Harmon, Oak Park Democrat; Dan Kotowski, Park Ridge Democrat; Terry Link, Waukegan Democrat; Julie Morrison, Deerfield Democrat; John Mulroe, Chicago Democrat; Michael Noland, Elgin Democrat
Pamela Althoff, McHenry Republican; Michael Connelly, Lisle Republican; Kirk Dillard, Hinsdale Republican; Dan Duffy, Lake Barrington Republican; Linda Holmes, Aurora Democrat; Karen McConnaughay, St. Charles Republican; Matt Murphy, Palatine Republican; Jim Oberweis, Sugar Grove Republican; Christine Radogno, Lemont Republican
On sweeping pension-cut bill
How suburban lawmakers voted on a more sweeping plan to cut pensions for teachers, state workers, lawmakers and university employees, which was defeated 23-30 in the Illinois Senate.
Pamela Althoff, McHenry Republican; Michael Connelly, Lisle Republican; Kirk Dillard, Hinsdale Republican; Dan Duffy, Lake Barrington Republican; Don Harmon, Oak Park Democrat; Karen McConnaughay, St. Charles Republican; Matt Murphy, Palatine Republican; Michael Noland, Elgin Democrat; Jim Oberweis, Sugar Grove Republican; Christine Radogno, Lemont Republican
Melinda Bush, Grayslake Democrat; Linda Holmes, Aurora Democrat; Dan Kotowski, Park Ridge Democrat; Terry Link, Waukegan Democrat; Julie Morrison, Deerfield Democrat; John Mulroe, Chicago Democrat
Tom Cullerton, Villa Park Democrat
Biss' plan would have cut annual cost-of-living pension increases, raised the retirement age and required local school districts to start paying into a 401(k)-style plan for teachers, among other things.
But whether it would pass muster under an Illinois Constitution that says benefits cannot be "diminished" was a key question in the debate.
As a result, a proposal from Senate President John Cullerton was approved by a 30-22 vote.
Cullerton's plan would affect only teachers and leaves other retirees alone. It would give teachers hired before 2011 a choice between a less generous yearly increase in their benefits, and keeping their current pension but giving up access to state-subsidized health care.
"It has the strongest argument to be constitutional," Cullerton said of his plan.
The limited scope, though, raised questions about whether his cuts would save enough money to be worth doing.
"This doesn't do enough for us to put the check in the box on pension reform," said state Sen. Matt Murphy, a Palatine Republican.
"No matter what we do, it's going to be painful to someone," said Senate Republican Leader Christine Radogno of Lemont.
Biss' plan could have saved the state nearly $2 billion a year in its ballooning retirement payments.
The mixed action in the Senate leaves lawmakers without a clear picture of what happens next.
Cullerton's proposal approved in the Senate has received almost no public vetting in the House, where Biss' plan perhaps enjoyed the most support among myriad proposals.
As the state's nearly $100 billion in pension debt continues to grow, the rising yearly payments limit how much money Illinois has to pay for schools, care for the disabled and many other programs.
Cullerton has drafted legislation that would cut benefits for other public employees, but it wasn't called for a vote after the teachers part nearly wasn't approved.
In fact, on a first vote, Senate Democrats were one vote shy. They tried again shortly after and got to the 30 votes they needed to send it to the Illinois House.
Some Democrats, including state Sen. Michael Noland of Elgin, voted "yes" for both bills.
"I will be voting for any meaningful measure on pension reform," Noland said.