Fittest loser
Article posted: 11/29/2012 4:40 AM

Community's rights over individuals'?

text size: AAA

Elgin Mayor Dave Kaptain's quote about protecting individual rights by way of "the rights of the entire community" when questioned on the tree cutting moratorium in Elgin smacks of hypocrisy and contradiction at its very core.

A community, last time I checked, was composed of individual residents who so happen to live in a common location and share a common government. So by protecting the individual rights of your residents, Mr. Kaptain, you are naturally protecting the rights of the community in its entirety, but not the other way around.


How can you preserve individual rights in Elgin by way of passing ordinances that prevent lawful landowners from cutting down their own trees? That to me seems more like prohibiting the rights of residents in Elgin more than you claim you are protecting them. A government that attacks the rights of its residents in the name of some idealized community is what Kaptain must have been referring to, because a "community" in and of itself has no right over the very residents who comprise it and by principle alone shouldn't.

Mayor Kaptain and the entire Elgin City Council are violating the rights of every single resident of Elgin by forbidding them to act in their own interest when it comes to their trees.

And as a baffled resident in reading Mr. Kaptain's most recent statements I would like to ask a follow-up question of my own to further clarify things. Mr. Kaptain what kind of community is that?

Shane Nowak


Comments ()
We are now using Facebook comments to offer a more inclusive, social and constructive discussion. Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.

This article filed under

Latest Video


Most Commented
Top Jobs

    View all Top Jobs Place a job ad



    • Newspaper next section - Newspaper next section Report card checker - report card checker
    • Dh innovation award 2 - Dh innovation award 2 Zillow /real estate page
    • Discuss refer On Guard series
    • Newspaper archives -- Monday or anyday Mike North



    Connect with a business or service in your area fast. First select a town, then enter a search term or choose one of the listed popular searches:

    Don't see your town listed? Visit our full directory to begin your search.