Breaking News Bar
updated: 9/8/2017 10:48 AM

How does Chicago stack up against contenders for Amazon HQ2?

hello
Success - Article sent! close
  • Amazon.com Inc. is looking for a North American city to build a massive second headquarters -- and Chicago wants to be in the running.

    Amazon.com Inc. is looking for a North American city to build a massive second headquarters -- and Chicago wants to be in the running.
    (AP File Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais, 2012)

 
 

Amazon.com Inc. is looking for a North American city to build a massive second headquarters -- and Chicago wants to be in the running. Dubbed "HQ2," the site will probably cost more than $5 billion, take up to two decades to develop and employ 50,000 people. Whatever city gets chosen will be transformed by Amazon, which has already changed the character of its native Seattle, setting in motion a building boom and rising rents.

"Seattle doesn't have enough capacity for their growth," says Lisa Picard, chief executive officer of Equity Office, one of the biggest office landlords in the U.S. "That's the biggest issue." HQ2 will be a major economic boon for the city that successfully woos Amazon, and mayors, including Chicago's Rahm Emanuel and Jim Strickland of Memphis, Tennessee, are already raising their hands. So are officials in Philadelphia, Hartford, Connecticut; Tulsa, Oklahoma; St. Louis and Rhode Island, demonstrating that Amazon will wield a lot of leverage in making its choice.

"I would suspect they go for places with capacity and reasonable costs of living and strong lifestyle," says Picard, whose company is owned by Blackstone Group LP. "That's a game-changer for places that are needing a new industry."

Here are some of the options:

Chicago

Pros:

• Mayor Emanuel has already had several conversations with Amazon about putting the new HQ in America's Second City, according to the Chicago Sun-Times.

• Heavy concentration of operations, marketing, finance and sales employees to poach from other industries.

Cons:

• One of the few major U.S. cities without a significant tech presence.

Atlanta

Pros:

• Major flight hub and home of UPS, giving Amazon's ever-growing shipping division a solid pool of expertise and a centralized North American location.

• Large, dynamic metropolitan area of nearly 6 million, which already hosts the headquarters of major corporations like Coca-Cola, Delta and Home Depot.

Cons:

• Amazon prides itself on its urban Seattle locations being walkable and bikeable. A more suburban city like Atlanta may contradict that spirit.

Toronto

Pros:

• Already home to 800 Amazon employees and features a large pool of high-quality computer science and engineering graduates.

• Potentially easier to hire people from abroad because of more open tone on immigration from the government. Also offers the benefit of government-funded health care.

Cons:

• Hiring so many people outside the U.S. might make Amazon a bigger target than it already is for President Donald Trump.

Pittsburgh

Pros:

• Home to top AI and robotics university Carnegie Mellon

• Has industrial manufacturing background useful for Amazon's warehousing operations

• Close to major distribution hubs

Cons:

• Located far from other major cities and tech hubs.

Brooklyn

Pros:

• Locating in New York would give Amazon access to the world's top pool of finance and media talent, proximity to fashion as well as a growing tech scene.

• Creative center would draw young employees looking for a locale that's even hipper than Seattle.

Cons:

• Rent prices are already high, one of the reasons locals in Seattle are pushing back against the company's expansion there.

• Limited space for new construction.

Austin

Pros:

• Close to the distribution and business hub of Dallas.

• Home to a hip, young population that could be a draw for potential employees.

• No state income tax for employees.

• Home to Whole Foods, which Amazon recently acquired.

Cons:

• Smaller than other U.S. options.

• Corporate "margin tax" penalizes unprofitable companies.

Memphis

Pros:

• Large pool of university talent.

• Lower wages and rents than in more established tech hubs.

• State has been focused on attracting new tech companies to the area.

Cons:

• Lack of a nearby major international airport, smaller size.

Los Angeles

Pros:

• Already home to Amazon's quickly-growing video business.

• Westcoast time zone could increase synergies with the Seattle office.

Cons:

• Urban sprawl, traffic and high home prices could make it difficult to hire the number of people Amazon requires.

Detroit (Wild card)

Pros:

• Low rent, potential for bigger tax breaks for a city and state looking for diversification from manufacturing.

• Trying to turn around a city is the kind of statement Jeff Bezos might want to make.

Cons:

• May be a harder sell to move top engineers and other Amazon employees there.

• Smaller size, limited tech scene.

Other potential locales include Salt Lake City, Dallas, Vancouver and even Mexico City, says Kenneth A. Lewis, a partner at architecture firm Skidmore, Owings & Merrill. ''It's a vibrant city with an educated workforce, a very business-positive community and culture, culture, culture.''

-- -- --

With assistance from Spencer Soper.

Article Comments ()
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.