LARAMIE, Wyo. -- Josh Allen eluded three would-be tacklers on a wild touchdown scramble from 7 yards out in the third overtime to lift Wyoming to a 40-34 win over Northern Illinois in a game that began nearly two hours late Saturday night due to thunderstorms and ended early Sunday morning.
Christian Hagan missed a 38-yard field goal wide left at the start of the third overtime for Northern Illinois (0-1).
Brian Hill finished with 125 yards rushing and 2 touchdowns, including a 5-yarder in the second overtime for Wyoming (1-0). The junior, who was the 8th-leading rusher in the FBS last year, went over 100 yards for the 12th time in his career. Drew Hare's 1-yard scoring run for Northern Illinois forced a third overtime.
At the start of the first overtime, Hare fumbled the snap on 3rd and goal from the 2 and Wyoming's Logan Wilson recovered.
Allen's 2-yard scoring toss to Jacob Hollister snapped a 20-all tie late in the third quarter, but Hare led the Huskies on a 77-yard drive, converting a fourth-and-10 before hitting wide-open Shane Wimann for a 19-yard touchdown with 1:13 left in the regulation.
Wyoming freshman Cooper Rothe missed a 48-yard field goal at the end of regulation and 37-yarder at the end of the first overtime.
"It was a phenomenal win," Cowboys coach Craig Bohl said. "We have steps to go, but we're starting to see the stamp of the program we want to have."
Allen, a sophomore who took only 13 snaps last season before suffering a broken clavicle, made his second career start. His winning run came on a third-down, play-action bootleg right, but Ladell Fleming forced him back to the left and Allen spun away from Jawuan Johnson and Sean Folliard, then cut straight up and ended a game that lasted four hours and 14 minutes.
"Coach told me to be smart about it and I probably should have thrown it away," Allen said. "I looked back and our guys were there (to block), cut it back and made a guy miss and found a hole and dived in. Felt great."
Allen finished 19 of 29 for 245 yards and two touchdowns. Hare was 24 of 39 for 329 yards -- the fourth-best output of his career -- with 3 touchdowns, and Kenny Golladay had 10 receptions for 144 yards and 2 TD catches. He also rushed for 82 yards and another score.
The game was delayed one hour, 50 minutes by a series of thunderstorms. Kickoff didn't occur until 10:20 p.m. and the contest ended at 2:34 a.m.
The late start and three-OT affair was an unusual experience, Golladay said.
"It was new for me," he said. "I'm sure just like everybody else, probably. I've never done that. I don't know who has. It was a fun game. It just didn't come out in our favor."
Northern Illinois coach Rod Carey said his team made too many mistakes. "The kids played hard, but we've got a lot to correct," he said. "I think there's enough blame to go around with all the sloppiness there was. Give Wyoming credit. We knew they were going to be improved, and they were everything we thought they were."
Andrew Wingard, who led Wyoming with 12 tackles, twice stopped Golladay at the 2 in the first overtime when it appeared the fleet receiver would score. Mycial Allen led Northern Illinois with 13 stops.
The NIU view:
Northern Illinois is the winningest team of the Mid-American Conference over the last decade, so last year's 8-6, injury-plagued campaign, capped by a fourth-straight bowl game loss, left the team hungry for a strong start to 2016 and return to form. The Huskies struggled against an inspired Cowboys team that was among the worst in the FBS last year, at least statistically. Hare appears to be fully recovered from a torn Achilles tendon that sidelined him for the final five games of last season, but his fumble at the end of the first overtime was costly.
The Cowboys won only six games in coach Craig Bohl's first two seasons, but this victory was a major step up for the beleaguered program. Bohl has vowed to restore the program "the right way" which might not be the fastest way, but his team made significant strides in the opener, being competitive throughout the whole game, which didn't occur very often last year.
The defense looked much quicker and rose to the occasion at several key points, including shutting out the Huskies in two of the three overtimes and stopped seven of eight drives after giving up two first-quarter touchdowns.
The Huskies visit South Florida, the fourth meeting between the schools. The Bulls won the last encounter 27-3 in the final International Bowl, played in Toronto following the 2009 campaign to lead the series 2-1.
The Cowboys travel to Nebraska, which leads the all-time series 7-0, including a 37-34 win in 2013's season opener in Lincoln. Wyoming racked up 602 yards against the No. 18 Cornhuskers and nearly overcame a late 16-point deficit.