Breaking News Bar
posted: 4/27/2013 4:59 AM

Allure of financial gain blinds many to the obvious red flags

Success - Article sent! close

A few weeks ago, I discovered I was not getting all the emails sent to me by readers, which induced me to examine my spam file. Dismayed to find that it contained many letters from friends and readers that I should have received, I disabled the spam filter, and reconciled myself to the daily task of weeding out all the junk mail by sight.

In doing this, I quickly discovered that the spam filter had shielded me from a torrent of Internet "scam mails" originating abroad. During the previous two weeks, I received 62 of them, which astounded me.

I set up a scam folder, which grows day by day. The industry has grown to sizable proportions, which makes it worth an article.

The pitch: What all scam mails have in common is a story about a large sum of money available to me, the amounts typically running into the millions of dollars.

Someone recently deceased may have left it for me in their will, or it may be in a bank account of someone who has died without heirs, whom I must impersonate in order to collect. It may be in a strong box hidden in a foreign country by an ex-dictator, or one of his henchmen, which will be sent to me if I agree to receive it.

Another possibility is that the money is due me under a contract I had with the United Nations or some other official agency, which somehow I forgot about. Or I won a sweepstakes that I can't remember having entered. I have also been offered the personal fortunes of multiple widows about to die who need a trusted person to manage their money for the public good.

The central contradiction: The stories are based on a contradiction that should be obvious to anyone whose critical faculties have not disengaged: In almost every case, the money to be paid requires that the recipient be identified, yet the letter does not address the recipient by name. It is addressed to "Dear Friend" or "Hello," or "Sir/Madam" or "Hello Beloved," or "Attention Unpaid Beneficiary." Real names don't work because scam mail is disseminated through mass Internet mailings, the low cost of which makes the business viable.

Who is the target? The scamsters don't expect many replies, but they don't need many to thrive. An analogy that comes to mind is a performance by a hypnotist I attended many years ago. The hypnotist came out on the stage and announced "You are getting very sleepy ," whereupon two people in the audience of about 300 promptly fell fast asleep. These two people were highly vulnerable to suggestion. In a similar vein, the scamsters are looking for the few who are highly responsive to the allures of their pitch.

The money allure: The prospect of obtaining a large sum of money causes the critical faculties of some people to shut down. The scamsters differ widely among themselves on what the optimal figure is to cause a shutdown without straining credibility, but in my sample they are all larger than $1 million, range up to $80 million, and average about $5 million.

Source allure: The scamsters identify themselves in ways designed to impress recipients but discourage inquiries. The most frequently employed identity in my sample is an official of a government agency, a central bank, or a large private bank located in Nigeria, Ghana, Thailand, Korea, Spain, Burkina Faso or Hong Kong. None are in the U.S. Soldiers figure prominently, ranging from sergeants to generals. And there are many widows, some but not all with distinguished deceased husbands. Scamsters seem to believe that widowship is a highly credible status.

A few of the more interesting scams are disguised as counterfrauds, where the writer laments the epidemic of fraud, is highly critical of the rascals perpetrating them, who are trashing the reputation of their country. They then proceed to assure the recipient that there just might be some money in an account that bears their name, and they can learn the truth about it only from them.

The payoff: The recipient who responds is told about a very minor issue that must be settled before the money can be delivered -- removing it will require a small payment, maybe $125, which isn't much considering the millions that will soon be coming. If this is paid, another problem is discovered, and this one might cost a little more, but now the victim has an investment to protect. The game continues as long as the victim is willing to play.

Resistance: Some of the scams are actually pretty well designed, and I can understand how some people, especially if they are in a financial bind, might be tempted. Perhaps the most powerful deterrent is exposure to multiple illustrations of the same scam. If you know someone who is being tempted, send me their scam mail and I will reply with multiple versions of the same scam drawn from my scam mail folder. If that doesn't stop them, nothing will.

• Contact Jack Guttentag via his website at

2012, Inman News Service

Article Comments ()
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.