
Controversial remarks by Union Pacific’s CEO caught on video have stirred up proceedings involving an $85 billion railroad merger, with federal regulators issuing a rare rebuke over concerns about “actual or threatened retaliation” against stakeholders.
Freight giants Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern are proposing a union to create the nation’s first transcontinental railroad.
On Wednesday, the U.S. Surface Transportation Board ordered UP to make public a video of a speech by CEO Jim Vena to shippers where he suggested that customers opposing the merger could face higher rates.
“The board has serious concerns about whether Vena’s statement … may be influencing certain stakeholders’ willingness to participate in this proceeding or share their own views without fear of commercial repercussions,” the STB said in a ruling.
“The board will not tolerate actual or threatened retaliation against a stakeholder for participating in this or any other proceeding before the board. Retaliation, whether perceived or actual, can seriously undermine the integrity of the board’s processes.”
Meanwhile, “Union Pacific does not retaliate against customers,” the railroad said in a statement.
“A customer’s position on the merger will not determine its rates or how we deliver service. Customers should participate freely and candidly in the STB review.”
Adding to the brouhaha, freight rival CPKC on Oct. 30 requested the STB to terminate “this poisoned proceeding now,” arguing UP’s hardball tactics had scared off many shippers from expressing opposition to the merger.
Numerous railroads and shippers contend a merger will stifle competition, while some suburbs have warned it could spike freight traffic and cause delays.
UP and Norfolk Southern argue that joining forces will increase efficiency, reliability and expedite deliveries.
In a speech to the Southwest Association of Rail Shippers in March, Vena said: “We’re willing to make deals with customers. So come and see us. Talk about what you need to move ahead with us and how we put this thing forward.
“If we don’t do that, Union Pacific will still be there. And if I stick around, which I probably will, I’ll probably increase everybody’s rates that said they didn’t want a seamless railroad by 3 or 4 extra percent to teach you a lesson.”
UP officials suggested the CEO was joking, saying he “is known for being a dynamic speaker,” and noting Trains magazine characterized the session as “Vena’s Comedy Club.”
“The fact is there are more than 1,000 participants in the merger proceeding. Of those, more than 500 are customers who support the merger and represent more than 30% of Union Pacific’s volume. We continue to work with customers to discuss the benefits and welcome tough questions,” the railroad said.
CPKC argues that even if Vena’s remarks were viewed as “a twisted attempt at humor, that would not overcome their impact on rail customers’ perception of the risks associated with participating in this proceeding.”
Vena also criticized the STB, noting it “takes them fricking months and way too long to make a decision. They need to speed up. Tell us whether we’re right or tell us whether we’re wrong. You have a responsibility to do things and let’s get it done.
A recent Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning report predicted merger fallout would include: about 6% more freight trains between Geneva and Northlake, and about 20% more between Northlake and Chicago’s West Side; longer trains; more pollution; and delays for Metra commuters.
UP contends the combined railroad will remove more than 2 million truckloads of cargo off congested roads, easing traffic congestion in the region, and reducing vehicle crashes.
The video, which UP had sought to keep confidential, is available at up.com/about-us/contact-us/play. The remarks about rate increases come at the end of Vena’s roughly 50-minute speech.
mpyke@dailyherald.com




