Cutler's great and all, but to Butkus, defense still key to Bears' success

Published9/8/2009 12:06 AM

The way Dick Butkus sees it, Jay Cutler would be "in Canada somewhere" had he tried to force George Halas to trade him.

The Hall of Fame linebacker also believes his former team won't go anywhere unless the defense holds up. Oh sure, having a franchise quarterback helps, but what happens on the other side of the ball will determine whether the Bears get back to the playoffs.


"If they don't improve from last year, I don't know if God could really help them at quarterback," Butkus said Monday in a phone interview.

In Chicago, many fans consider the new rocket-armed quarterback a gift from above.

The Bears had been searching for a franchise quarterback since the Sid Luckman era when they made the trade for Cutler following his fallout with the Broncos. Suddenly, expectations soared. The Bears are eyeing another playoff run after going 9-7 and missing the postseason for the second straight year.

That means, all eyes - or most eyes - are on the Pro Bowl quarterback. Butkus has at least one trained on the other side of the ball, where the defense is trying to recapture some of the dominant form that spurred a playoff appearance in 2005 and a run to the Super Bowl in 2006.

Since then, there have been a long line of breakdowns in health and execution, resulting in mediocre play - particularly against the pass.

The Bears ranked 30th in that area a year ago, with the secondary struggling and the line failing to produce enough pressure. Coach Lovie Smith decided changes were in order, so he took the play-calling duties from Bob Babich while hiring defensive line coach Rod Marinelli and defensive backs coach Jon Hoke. But the shakeup probably won't matter much if linebacker Brian Urlacher, defensive tackle Tommie Harris and Charles Tillman are limited by injuries.

by signing up you agree to our terms of service

The good news for the Bears is that Urlacher was able to gear his off-season routine toward conditioning rather than rehabilitation, as he did a year ago following neck surgery. Harris remains a bit of a question mark after battling knee and hamstring problems the past few years. His participation in the preseason was limited, and Tillman practiced Monday for the first time since back surgery in July.

An effective Harris draws opponents' attention and takes the pressure off the rest of the line, which in turn helps the defensive backs. Even so, Butkus wouldn't pin the Bears' chances on him.

"When I was watching the Bears that Super Bowl year on TV and when I'm following the set and the camera is following the play," Butkus said, "and there's a fumble by the receiver and Tommie Harris is there recovering a fumble, it's telling me that this guy plays fast. And he's all over the place. I was looking forward to seeing him do that last year, but he was nowhere to be found.

"Of course, that's the injury factor. I think it's very important for him to be able to get back to where he was a couple of years ago because it will require a little bit different philosophy on offenses and help Urlacher or whoever's playing in the middle to make some plays."


And what about Urlacher? Can he be the player he was?

"It'll be interesting," said Butkus, who was in Dallas on Monday to speak at the Herbstreit Varsity Football Series Games as part of his "I Play Clean" campaign to educate young players about the dangers of performance-enhancing drugs.

The fact that Urlacher is healthier is a good sign, and the Bears' legend expects the star linebacker to have a good season.

It doesn't hurt that a top-tier quarterback is running the offense and taking some pressure off the defense, even if there are questions about Cutler's ability to lead. His record as a starter is 17-20 and he just forced his way out of Denver over new coach Josh McDaniels' pursuit of Matt Cassel.

"Halas probably would have handled it where Jay Cutler would probably be playing in Canada somewhere," Butkus said.

Instead, he's a big source of optimism in Chicago even though his transition has been a bit bumpy.

First, he and Urlacher found themselves denying a rift at the start of training camp, thanks to comments Vikings receiver Bobby Wade made to a Minneapolis radio station. The former Bear said Urlacher questioned Cutler's manhood and used a profanity to describe him during a conversation in Las Vegas. Cutler also offended receiver Devin Hester with a comment after one of the preseason games, although that issue was quickly smoothed over.

More important, the Bears finally resolved a big issue at the most important position.

"I think they're way ahead on the quarterback front, so the pressure I think is swinging over on the defense," Butkus said. "You've got to give them the ball and get some turnovers and play like you usually play them. And it should be fine. And put Hester back on the special teams and everything will be fine."


Get articles sent to your inbox.

Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.