Movie review: Romanian documentary 'Collective' uncovers rot of healthcare corruption

  • The documentary "Collective" follows journalists, including Catalin Tolontan, as they investigate how Romanian hospitals diluted disinfectant.

    The documentary "Collective" follows journalists, including Catalin Tolontan, as they investigate how Romanian hospitals diluted disinfectant. Courtesy of Magnolia Pictures

  • The documentary "Collective" follows journalists, including Catalin Tolontan, as they investigate how Romanian hospitals diluted disinfectant.

    The documentary "Collective" follows journalists, including Catalin Tolontan, as they investigate how Romanian hospitals diluted disinfectant. Courtesy of Magnolia Pictures

  • The documentary "Collective" uncovers corruption involving Romanian hospitals in the aftermath of a nightclub fire.

    The documentary "Collective" uncovers corruption involving Romanian hospitals in the aftermath of a nightclub fire. Courtesy of Magnolia Pictures

 
 
Updated 11/20/2020 9:41 AM

"Collective" - ★ ★ ★

A politicized health care crisis, horrifyingly unnecessary death, a crucial election. "Collective," a piercing documentary about corruption in Romania, may not directly concern current events but it feels urgent and vital just the same.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
 

In 2015, a fire swept through a Bucharest nightclub without emergency exits. Footage early in "Collective" captures the frighteningly fast flames engulfing the crowded club just after, fittingly, a punk band screams a song about endemic corruption in the Eastern European country. The fire left 27 dead and 180 injured. But the real scandal came after; another 37 people died of burn wounds that shouldn't have been life threatening.

It's in that aftermath that Romanian director Alexander Nanau began trailing the journalists of Gazeta Sporturilor, a sports tabloid that under editor Catalin Tolontan consistently advanced the story with dogged reporting. They uncovered the heinous reason for the out-of-control bacteria in Romanian hospitals: a firm called Hexi Pharma, along with a mafia network of politically appointed hospital managers, were diluting disinfectant. Seldom will you find an uglier or more apt metaphor for corruption than -- in one of the Sporturilor's breaks -- the image of maggots crawling in an uncleaned wound.

So, no, "Collective" is not a walk in the park. But it's admirably awake to the cause-and-effect tragedies that can follow seemingly slight or obscure governmental decisions. As a journalism drama, it's as absorbing as "Spotlight" and more sober than "All the President's Men." Filmed in an observation style, there are meetings with whistleblowers, photo stakeouts and deep data dives -- the nuts and bolts of reporting. But scoops yield no high-fiving celebrations, just mournful disbelief at the wanton cruelty and ineptitude they uncover. "The story is so mind blowing I'm afraid people will think we're crazy," one reporter says.

"Collective" takes a turn midway, shifting its focus to a newly installed health minister, Vlad Voiculescu, who takes over following the resignation of his under-pressure predecessor. A former patients' rights activist, Voiculescu is strikingly more candid and gives Nanau remarkable access to his meetings. He seeks immediate reforms to the hospital system but is continually met by bureaucratic red tape and, eventually, a pseudo scandal propagated by a conservative news network. Still, he ever more bluntly beats back against the rot. After six months, his work hangs in the balance in a national election that will see the populist party easily defeat foes of corruption and turn Voiculescu out of a job. "Collective," a document of a modern corruption that can fester and thrive anywhere, ends with a mortifying shudder and tears at a gravesite.

by signing up you agree to our terms of service
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
 

• • •

Directed by: Alexander Nanau

Other: A Magnolia Pictures release. On demand. Unrated but contains violent imagery. In Romanian with subtitles. 109 minutes

0 Comments
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
 
Article Comments ()
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.