advertisement

Brooklyn bishop accused by 2nd man of sex abuse in the 1970s

NEW YORK (AP) - The Roman Catholic bishop of Brooklyn, already under a church investigation for alleged sex abuse, has been accused by a second man of abuse in the 1970s, when the bishop was a parish priest in New Jersey.

Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio 'œrepeatedly sexually abused'ť Samier Tadros starting when he was about 6 years old, according to a March 9 letter that Tadros' lawyer sent to the attorney representing the Archdiocese of Newark. The letter alleges the abuse happened in Holy Rosary Church in Jersey City.

DiMarzio has previously denied the accusations made by the first accuser. In a statement to The Associated Press, he also denied the accusation leveled by Tadros. 'œThere is absolutely no truth to this allegation,'ť he said. 'œThis is clearly another attempt to destroy my name and discredit what I have accomplished in my service to God and His people.'ť

Joseph Hayden, DiMarzio's attorney, said in an email to the AP, 'œWe have uncovered conclusive evidence of Bishop DiMarzio's innocence.'ť Hayden declined to share the evidence with the AP.

DiMarzio's case has drawn interest because it is among the first conducted according to procedures Pope Francis issued under a new church law that went into effect last June.

The procedures - known in Latin as Vos Estis Lux Mundi, or You are the Light of the World - were issued in an apostolic letter that addresses how the church will handle claims against bishops and other ranking church officials accused of abuse or covering it up. The rules direct archbishops to lead the investigation of an accused bishop in his jurisdiction. In this case the archbishop of New York is Cardinal Timothy Dolan.

Mitchell Garabedian, an attorney for both of DiMarzio's accusers, told the AP that Tadros stepped forward after hearing from a family member that another man, 57-year-old Mark Matzek, had accused DiMarzio. Matzek also accused the late Rev. Albert Mark of sexually abusing him in the mid-1970s, when both priests were assigned to St. Nicholas Church, also in Jersey City.

The two men live in different states, Garabedian said, and have never met. 'œWe have two separate, discreet claims,'ť he said.

Tadros, now 46, has demanded $20 million in compensation. Hayden said, 'œBishop DiMarzio will never agree to a settlement of these claims.'ť

Last November, the AP reported that Garabedian planned to file suit on Matzek's behalf in New Jersey. But he said he put the plan on hold after the Archdiocese of New York asked whether Matzek would cooperate with Dolan's investigation. Garabedian said both men, as well as a family member of Tadros, are prepared to answer questions from Dolan's investigators.

Dolan has retained New York attorney John O'Donnell and the law firm of Herbert Smith Freehills to conduct the investigation. The firm in turn has hired a risk management company founded by former FBI director Louis Freeh to assist in the inquiry. Freeh was named in 2011 to lead an investigation into Pennsylvania State University and its handling of sex abuse claims against former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, which led to a report critical of university officials.

Under the church's new procedures, O'Donnell said, Dolan's investigation will be submitted to the Vatican, which will review the evidence and make a recommendation to Pope Francis.

Although Dolan will not personally conduct the investigation, he is to submit the investigation along with his 'œvotum," or vote, according to the new procedures.

Another provision says that the archbishop "is required to act impartially and free of conflicts of interest.'ť

But Garabedian and advocates for clergy abuse survivors have questioned Dolan's ability to remain neutral, citing comments he made during a Jan. 21 episode of his weekly 'œConversation with Cardinal Dolan'ť podcast.

'œBishop DiMarzio, I mean, I love the guy. He's a good friend," Dolan said. "He's never had an accusation against him in his whole life. But in November, somebody made an accusation from way, way, way, way, way, way back, 48 years or so ago. And as much as Bishop DiMarzio said, '~This is preposterous, this is ridiculous, this is unjust,' darn it, we have to take it seriously.'ť

Garabedian said Dolan's neutrality also is undermined by a decision to allow DiMarzio to remain in office during the investigation. In other instances of alleged clergy sexual abuse, some priests have been placed on administrative leave pending the outcome of a review of the accusations against them.

'œIt's very difficult for my clients to believe Cardinal Dolan could be neutral in this matter, after the public statement Cardinal Dolan made about his good friend Bishop DiMarzio,'ť Garabedian said.

Nicholas Cafardi, a canon lawyer and former chair of the U.S. bishops' National Review Board for the Protection of Children and Young People, said he believes that because Dolan has retained outside professionals to conduct the investigation, impartiality is assured.

"The fact that it's going to be based on what the professionals find means the requirement for impartiality has been met,'ť he said.

And O'Donnell, the attorney retained to conduct Dolan's investigation, noted in an email that 'œwhile Cardinal Dolan is to oversee the investigation, he is not the one to adjudicate the matter.'ť

In addition, O'Donnell said that because DiMarzio is a bishop, the decision to allow him to remain in office, or place him on administrative leave, rests with the Pope.

Earlier this year, the National Catholic Reporter, an independent Catholic newspaper, faulted the Vos Estis procedures for establishing a system of 'œbishops investigating fellow bishops.'ť The newspaper suggested that the new law be amended to require that accused bishops are investigated by archbishops from other parts of the country.

Anne Barrett Doyle, co-director of BishopAccountability.org, a group that catalogs information about clergy sex abuse, said Dolan's remarks and the decision to allow DiMarzio to remain in office during the investigation send a discouraging message to abuse survivors.

'œHow can Cardinal Dolan expect that any witnesses or whistleblowers will want to come forward under these conditions?" she said.

_______

AP investigative researcher Randy Herschaft in New York contributed to this report.

_______

Contact AP's global investigative team at Investigative@ap.org.

In this May 28, 2020, photo, people buy ice cream across the street from St. Nicholas Church in Jersey City, N.J. Mitchell Garabedian, an attorney for two alleged victims of Roman Catholic Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, told the Associated Press that Samier Tadros, 46, stepped forward after hearing that another man, 57-year-old Mark Matzek, had accused DiMarzio of sexually abusing him in the mid-1970s, when he was assigned to St. Nicholas Church. Joseph Hayden, DiMarzio's attorney, said he has evidence showing the accusations made by both men are false. (AP Photo/Jessie Wardarski) The Associated Press
This May 28, 2020 photo shows St. Nicholas Church in Jersey City, N.J. Mitchell Garabedian, an attorney for two alleged victims of Roman Catholic Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, told the Associated Press that Samier Tadros, 46, stepped forward after hearing that another man, 57-year-old Mark Matzek, had accused DiMarzio of sexually abusing him in the mid-1970s, when he was assigned to St. Nicholas Church. Joseph Hayden, DiMarzio's attorney, said he has evidence showing the accusations made by both men are false. (AP Photo/Jessie Wardarski) The Associated Press
This May 28, 2020 photo shows the Holy Rosary Roman Catholic Church in Jersey City, N.J. Samier Tadros, 46, claims Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, who was assigned to the church, 'œrepeatedly sexually abused' him starting when he was about 6 years old, according to a March 9, 2020 letter that Tadros' lawyer sent to the Archdiocese of Newark. Tadros has asked for $20 million in compensation. DiMarzio's lawyer said the accusation is not true and that DiMarzio will never agree to a settlement. (AP Photo/Jessie Wardarski) The Associated Press
This May 28, 2020 photo shows an entrance to the Holy Rosary Roman Catholic Church in Jersey City, N.J. Samier Tadros, 46, claims Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, who was assigned to the church, 'œrepeatedly sexually abused' him starting when he was about 6 years old, according to a March 9, 2020 letter that Tadros' lawyer sent to the Archdiocese of Newark. Tadros has asked for $20 million in compensation. DiMarzio's lawyer said the accusation is not true and that DiMarzio will never agree to a settlement. (AP Photo/Jessie Wardarski) The Associated Press
FILE - In this Nov. 14, 2007 file photo, Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio of Brooklyn, N.Y., speaks during a news conference at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops fall meeting in Baltimore. DiMarzio, under a church investigation for alleged sex abuse since January 2020, has been accused by a second man of abuse in the 1970s, when he was a parish priest in New Jersey. DiMarzio has denied the accusations made by both men. (AP Photo/Steve Ruark, File) The Associated Press
Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the "flag" link in the lower-right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.