advertisement

Charges at Minnesota cop's trial offer jury range of options

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) - When a Minneapolis police officer shot and killed an unarmed woman who approached his squad car after calling 911, it was catastrophic. But was it murder?

Prosecutors have given jurors hearing the case against Mohamed Noor multiple options: second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter. The jury will ultimately decide whether any of the counts fit what happened the night of July 15, 2017, when Noor fatally shot Justine Ruszczyk Damond just minutes after the dual citizen of the U.S. and Australia who had phoned in a report of a possible sexual assault behind her home.

As Noor's trial prepares to enter its third week, defense attorneys not connected to the case see a larger and commonly used strategy to overcharge the case in a way that could make it easy for jurors to convict on the lesser manslaughter count.

"Juries like to be King Solomon," said Earl Gray, an attorney on the team that successfully defended former Minnesota officer Jeronimo Yanez against a manslaughter charge in the 2016 shooting death of Philando Castile during a traffic stop. "They want to split the baby and give each side half."

"Prosecution is like hunting," said another defense attorney, Marsh Halberg, who has been sitting in on some of the key testimony. "You throw a lot of pellets up in the air and you don't care which one brings down the bird. Obviously you would always like to get (a conviction on) the highest charge but you want to leave at the end of the day with some conviction."

Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman was under intense community pressure and international scrutiny as he decided whether to charge Noor in Damond's death, which had led to a police chief's resignation. Freeman let it slip in an unguarded moment captured on video in December 2017 that he didn't have enough evidence at that point to charge Noor, saying investigators "haven't done their job." When Freeman finally filed charges in March 2018, he said the evidence clearly fit the legal definitions of third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter.

But Noor's legal team and other local defense attorneys said the third-degree murder charge was an overreach. Prosecutors added the second-degree murder charge late last year. The presumptive sentences vary from four years for the manslaughter charge to 12ˆ½ years for third-degree murder to 25ˆ½ years for second-degree murder.

Neither Halberg nor Gray think the jury is likely to convict Noor of third-degree murder, because the state statute requires jurors to find that someone acted with a "depraved mind, without regard for human life," a term so ill-defined and potentially confusing that prosecutors rarely use the charge.

In Noor's case, the prosecution's proposed jury instructions specifically avoid the term, and call it instead "an act eminently dangerous to others" and "performed without regard for human life ... committed in a reckless or wanton manner with the knowledge that someone may be killed and with a heedless disregard of that happening." The defense's proposed instructions do use the term "depraved mind." Judge Kathryn Quaintance has yet to rule.

Halberg was in court Thursday for testimony from Noor's partner, Officer Matthew Harrity, and viewed Harrity's body camera video as it was shown to the jury. Besides the heartache of seeing her dying on camera, Halberg said he was "touched by the humaneness of the two officers. They held her up and lowered her to the ground. Noor is doing chest compressions and they were yelling encouragement to her."

The care they showed her "really flies in the face of the depraved mind argument," he said.

Under Minnesota law, second-degree murder involves intentionally causing the death of another person, without premeditation. Second-degree manslaughter requires a finding that the defendant acted with "culpable negligence" in taking the chance of causing death or great bodily harm.

Halberg said it will be hard overcoming the defense that Noor's team has invoked that police can legally shoot if they have a reasonable fear that they're in danger. Noor's attorneys have argued that he heard a loud noise and feared an ambush. But prosecutors say there is no evidence of any threat to justify deadly force.

But some of the circumstances - Noor was in the passenger seat and fired his gun across Harrity through the driver's side window in a dark alley - may give the jury reasons to find him guilty of manslaughter, Halberg said.

"That's the charge that would fit the case," Gray said.

___

Check out the AP's complete coverage of Mohamed Noor's trial.

FILE - In this July 23, 2018, file photo, a poster of Justine Ruszczyk Damond is displayed at a news conference by attorneys for her family in Minneapolis. The Minneapolis woman who was fatally shot by a police officer in 2017 had spent a lifetime trying to help people and animals. Damond's relatives describe her as an animal lover who originally trained as a veterinary surgeon. (AP Photo/Amy Forliti, File) The Associated Press
Former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor, left, arrived with his defense attorneys Peter Wold, center, and Thomas Plunkett, right, on April 17, 2019, before another day of testimony in Noor's murder and manslaughter trial in Minneapolis. Noor is accused of fatally shooting an unarmed woman, Justine Ruszczyk Damond, on July 15, 2017, after she called 911 to report a possible sexual assault near her home. (AP Photo/Jeff Baenen) The Associated Press
Minneapolis police officer Matthew Harrity leaves the courtroom for lunch break with his attorney Fred Bruno, left, Thursday, April 18, 2019 in Minneapolis. Harrity, the partner of a Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot an unarmed woman testified Thursday that he didn’t fire his own weapon because he hadn’t fully analyzed the possible threat before his partner fired. (Leila Navidi/Star Tribune via AP) The Associated Press
Article Comments
Guidelines: Keep it civil and on topic; no profanity, vulgarity, slurs or personal attacks. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. If a comment violates these standards or our terms of service, click the "flag" link in the lower-right corner of the comment box. To find our more, read our FAQ.